Comsol -leaderboard other pages

Topics

The collider dividend

A particle collider is among the most ambitious projects a society can take on, and one whose worth is hard to capture in conventional economic terms. The instinctive argument for such machines rests on the knowledge they may produce, but no economist can attach a probability, let alone a monetary value, to a discovery that has not yet happened. For decades, this apparent impasse left funding decisions to the scientific case and to mostly qualitative socioeconomic narratives.

In 1945, Vannevar Bush, science adviser to two US presidents, identified the value of basic research in the foundations it may lay for practical progress. Robert Wilson, asked in Congress in 1969 whether the facility that became Fermilab would help defend the United States, answered that it would not, except by making the country worth defending. Reasoning of this kind is no longer enough on its own, and must now be backed by more quantitative evidence. The European Commission and national funding agencies, such as UK Research and Innovation (UKRI)  and France Stratégie, expect proposers of large research infrastructures to provide detailed cost-benefit analyses (CBAs), estimating their projects’ societal returns.

The most thorough evaluation of this kind yet performed concerns the LHC and its high-luminosity upgrade (HL-LHC), which entered the main installation phase when the machine completed its third run on 27 June 2026 (CERN Courier July/August 2026 p8). Four years of work will refit the ring with new hardware, including advanced focusing magnets, crab cavities to increase the collision rate and superconducting power lines. The corresponding CBA, developed over more than a decade at the University of Milan and CSIL, rests on a set of carefully chosen assumptions that provide crucial context for interpreting its results.

Discovery set aside

A CBA asks whether an investment’s benefits to society exceed its costs over a defined horizon. Any value available now is worth more than the same amount later, if only because it can earn a return in the meantime, so costs and benefits arising in different future years cannot simply be added: each must be scaled down, or “discounted”, the further ahead it lies. The inverse happens for past values, which must be “capitalised”. The difference between discounted (or capitalised) benefits and costs then yields the net present value (NPV), and a positive expected NPV indicates that the project passes the test. For the HL-LHC CBA, the accounting window ran from 1993, when expenditure attributable to the LHC programme began, to 2038, the machine’s expected end of operations at the time of the analysis, since revised to 2041. All sums, after discounting or capitalising at the 3% rate recommended by the European Commission for public projects, were expressed in constant 2016 Swiss francs, removing the effect of inflation.

Two methodological choices defined the whole exercise. The first was to set discoveries aside. Scientific outcomes at the frontier are subject to what economists call Knightian uncertainty: no probability distribution can be assigned to them, and any attempt to price the discovery of new physics would be arbitrary. The analysis, therefore, excluded the intrinsic value of scientific results altogether and asked a narrower, more disciplined question: do the measurable side effects of the investment – such as the training of early-stage researchers or the technological gains of supplier firms – repay its cost on their own? In this sense, the test was deliberately conservative. Whatever knowledge the machine ultimately produces comes on top of, not inside, the calculated return.

Odds on

The second choice concerns the counterfactual scenario. An upgrade cannot be assessed against a baseline of no machine at all. The LHC exists either way. The counterfactual scenario assumed an LHC that continues without the luminosity boost, under ordinary maintenance, until its discovery potential is exhausted. In the study’s timeline, that point was conjectured to fall in 2030. Data-taking then ceases, staff are redeployed and the tunnel is kept safe but idle. Constructing this alternative future in detail, down to its cost profiles, researcher numbers and procurement volumes, was among the hardest challenges of the study. It is also what allows every result to be read in incremental terms, as the difference between a world with and one without the high-luminosity upgrade.

Uncertainty was handled through Monte Carlo simulation. Fifteen critical parameters, among them the early-stage researchers’ salary premium, the suppliers’ sales multiplier, visitor numbers, taxpayers’ willingness to pay and total costs, were treated as random variables. Their distributions were calibrated from data where possible, and from earlier studies and structured expert judgement where they were not. Fifty thousand simulation runs then generated a probability distribution for the project’s NPV (see “Odds on” figure).

That distribution, rather than any point estimate, is what the model ultimately delivers to decision-makers. Against the LHC counterfactual, the HL–LHC incremental NPV is positive: each Swiss franc invested returns about 1.8 francs in societal benefits, and the chance of a positive social return is 94%.

Human capital

When the two scenarios are compared, the most valuable benefit of the HL-LHC to society is the people it trains (see “Measuring value” figure). Early-stage researchers, from technical, doctoral and postdoctoral trainees to young registered users of the experiments, acquire frontier technical and collaborative skills that employers reward for the rest of their careers. The benefit was measured as the lifetime salary premium these individuals earn relative to comparable peers who never passed through CERN, estimated from surveys of current students, alumni and more than 330 team leaders. Because a career lasts decades, benefits accruing to the final 2038 cohort extend to around 2080, long after the machine has been switched off.

Measuring value

In incremental terms, the salary premium for early-stage researchers accounts for roughly 40% of incremental benefits, the single largest share. The analysis assumes that employers pay the premium because training and hands-on experience make people more productive, so the figure is taken to gauge the value of skills flowing into the economy. The counterfactual clarifies why the share is so large: without the upgrade, the pipeline of early-stage researchers collapses once data-taking ends, whereas the HL–LHC keeps training thousands more through the 2030s (see “Two futures” figure). The FCC Feasibility Study predicts similar effects (CERN Courier May/June 2025 p9).

Each Swiss franc invested in the HL-LHC returns about 1.8 francs in societal benefits, and the chance of a positive social return is 94%

A new study of CERN’s overall impact over the past 25 years corroborates the pattern. In the 2025 CERN alumni survey, 95% of the almost 1000 respondents said that their experience at CERN had helped advance their careers, in fields ranging from software development to information technology, mechanical and industrial engineering, academia and financial services.

Technological spillovers

About 38% of the HL–LHC’s incremental benefits arise from technological spillovers. Firms that win high-tech procurement contracts learn from working with CERN and the experimental collaborations, file patents, refine processes and open new markets. The learning shows up as higher sales and profits in their business with customers other than CERN. The evidence base here is unusually rich, triangulated from a long-run econometric study of supplier accounts before and after their first CERN contract, a survey of more than 650 suppliers, and over two dozen in-depth case studies. In the model, each franc of high-tech procurement returns about three francs to the supplier in extra turnover or saved costs, a ratio first measured in surveys of CERN’s contractors in the 1980s, and confirmed by new evidence.

Two futures

A second kind of spillover is software released freely to the world. Updated packages initially developed for the LHC programme, such as ROOT and Geant4, were valued at what users would otherwise have paid for commercial equivalents.

Colliders and culture

A particle collider is also a cultural asset. About 5.7% of the HL–LHC’s incremental benefits stem from cultural engagement – mostly people travelling to the Geneva site or attending CERN’s touring exhibitions (see “Worth the trip” image). These are valued through the travel cost method, a standard technique that infers what an experience is worth from what visitors spend to reach it: fares, time, tickets. Websites, social media, volunteer computing, films and popular books are counted too, though each contributes far less than the visits. Visitor numbers rise and fall with discovery announcements and with CERN’s own capacity to attract and receive an audience, which makes outreach strategy part of the calculation.

Publications

Scientific publications might seem the most natural benefit of a research infrastructure, yet in the accounting their value is limited. The reason lies in methodology. What is measured is not the content of the papers, which would smuggle discovery value back in, but the volume of scientific production and its uptake. A paper’s production cost, in terms of its authors’ salaries, is assumed to cancel against the value of the time spent writing it, evaluated at what those hours would otherwise have earned, so that its net benefit comes entirely from downstream citations. A paper never cited is worth zero. The category matters less for its size than for what its treatment reveals about the method’s discipline: even the most visible benefit of science is valued only through observable, countable channels.

Public-good value

The final category captures the value citizens place on fundamental knowledge being created at all, analogous to the existence value of biodiversity or cultural heritage. This item accounts for about 11% of the incremental benefits and is estimated through direct taxpayer surveys. In February 2018, a representative sample of French adults was asked whether they would accept a specific, small annual tax rise to fund a new accelerator, the alternative being that research at the LHC gradually winds down. Across models, the average willingness to pay exceeded the €2.70 that a French adult contributed to CERN through taxes in 2017. Earlier experiments with students in Italy, France, Spain and the UK, a later survey of Swiss taxpayers, and more recent studies in eight further countries – with more than 10,000 respondents in total – all point in the same direction.

Worth the trip

The French survey also exposed an awareness gap. Only 46% of respondents had heard of CERN before the interview, compared with 89% for UNESCO, 86% for NASA and 77% for France’s own CNRS. Prior awareness was among the strongest predictors of willingness to pay, and the gap leaves headroom for the public value of CERN’s fundamental science to grow.

A sharper picture

Readers of earlier presentations on the socioeconomic impact of the HL–LHC will recognise these categories of benefits (CERN Courier September 2018 p51), but the picture has now sharpened in four ways. First, the analysis has fully embraced a probabilistic approach, with quantified simulation errors. Second, risk itself has become an object of analysis. Since cost overruns are the classic killer of Big Science, with the 1993 cancellation of the Superconducting Super Collider being a key example, the studies built a pessimistic scenario, pinning total costs above the reference value. Even then, the probability of a positive NPV stays around 80%. Third, the headline shares are now read strictly against the counterfactual, and the effect is remarkable. Cultural engagement, 13% of the HL–LHC’s total benefits, falls to about 6% incrementally, because some visitors come to CERN regardless of whether the upgrade happens. Publications rise from 2% to about 6%, because additional papers are only written if the machine runs. Fourth, the environmental dimension has more recently been incorporated into the evaluation of Big Science projects. A case in point is the FCC Feasibility Study, which accounts for the carbon footprint of construction and operation on the cost side, and for energy-efficiency technologies developed for the machine on the benefit side.

A conservative floor

The honest conclusion is double-edged. A social CBA of Big Science does not tell us whether the HL-LHC will find new physics, and no econometric methodology can. What it establishes is a floor. Even with new discoveries valued at zero, and under conservative assumptions throughout, the upgrade is very likely to repay society more than it costs, principally through the people it trains and the firms it transforms.

The HL-LHC is very likely to repay society more than it costs, principally through the people it trains and the firms it transforms

The approach is also portable. It has travelled from proton colliders to hadron therapy, synchrotron light sources, a protein database, the Einstein Telescope and Earth-observation satellites. Any major research infrastructure can be assessed the same way, provided the critical variables can be identified – their plausible ranges established from data and expert judgement – and the temptation to price potential discoveries resisted. Each application, moreover, feeds the next, since parameters estimated ex-post for one facility become the calibration base for appraising another. The economics of science, a young field grown alongside more than a decade of dialogue with CERN scientists, advances much like the instruments it studies. 

A collaboration at high luminosity

Bunch crossing

The ATLAS collaboration has approximately 6000 members from 262 institutes in 40 countries, about half of them scientific authors. This large and diverse community has spent the past few years carrying out detector operations, data analyses and upgrades all at once, through a global pandemic and a succession of geopolitical crises. As the High-Luminosity LHC (HL-LHC) era draws closer, the collaboration decided to find out where its members stand on fundamental strategic questions and how they feel about its organisation and operating model.

Collaborations in particle physics have not always been this large. The Gargamelle team that discovered weak neutral currents in 1973 counted 55 authors from seven European laboratories, with guests from Japan, the Soviet Union and the United States. The W boson was found a decade later by two collaborations, UA1 and UA2, of roughly 140 and 60 physicists, respectively. At LEP, the four experiments ALEPH, DELPHI, L3 and OPAL each counted several hundred physicists from a few tens of institutes. When ATLAS and CMS jointly measured the Higgs-boson mass in 2015, in the first paper the two collaborations signed together, the author list ran to 5154 names and filled 24 of the article’s 33 pages.

Most members plan to take part in the HL-LHC programme and stressed the importance of remaining engaged with the collaboration to successfully complete the upgrade

A collaboration of this scale can only be consulted through an organised, sustained effort. In the case of ATLAS, this meant establishing a working group of 14 members to draft survey questions, collecting responses from July to September 2024, and forming an analysis team of five to read and interpret the results, with each step of the process taking several months. Designed to be concise, focused and actionable, the “Big Survey” still comprised more than 200 questions. To limit the burden on participants and maximise reach, these were divided into four modules of approximately 20 minutes each, the first on strategic collaboration issues, the second on physics and performance, the third on operations, the upgrade and practical matters such as travel, meetings and remote working, and the fourth on career development and work culture.

Survey rates

Replies came from nearly 1500 members (see “Demographics” figure). The rate of participation rose steeply with seniority, from fewer than 10% of master’s and undergraduate students, engineers and technicians, and about 17% of PhD students, to around 30% of scientific authors with fewer than 5 years of authorship and nearly 60% of those with between 10 and 15. The overall response rate was slightly below 25% and was approximately uniform across world regions.

Demographics

The results were examined across demographic groups, compiled into an internal document and then discussed with the collaboration at large during plenary meetings. An online tool also allowed members to explore the correlations for themselves. The conclusions comprise 37 actions to address the areas of improvement identified in the survey, and many have already been implemented. For instance, all active members, not only scientific authors and students, now have access to the collaboration’s complete internal documentation, and the operational workload institutions must cover has been rebalanced towards those less engaged in upgrade construction.

The survey showed overall satisfaction. Asked whether the ATLAS organisational structure is well suited to current and future challenges in data-taking, analysis and upgrades, 62% of respondents agreed, and 14% disagreed (see “Four of two hundred” figure). Most plan to take part in the HL-LHC programme, and they stressed the importance of remaining engaged with the collaboration to successfully complete the upgrade, move smoothly from construction to operations with the new detector, and then sustain years of running to collect much larger datasets. Responses highlighted the need for simple, intuitive workflows and well-documented tools for data analysis. The collaboration is strengthening its documentation team to bring order and searchability to the sprawling records. Moreover, over the past few years, its many analysis frameworks have been consolidated into a few broadly used ones with common statistical tools. On the physics programme itself, respondents see much still to explore, with the caution that effort remains balanced across topics and analysis teams are sufficiently staffed.

Four of two hundred

Among the aspects examined in detail were participation in detector upgrade activities, the organisation of physics analyses and publications, and the long-term operation of the experiment. One finding stands out. Contributions such as detector operation and maintenance are regarded as insufficiently recognised by the broad scientific community and research institutions. While most respondents feel satisfied with the recognition received within the collaboration for their work in operations, a large share does not consider this work important for their career progression in particle physics. The actions proposed in response are to make the rules behind authorship, speaker selection and operational credit public on an accessible, single web page, so that committees outside ATLAS can weigh a member’s contributions, and to brief funding agencies more often on technical achievements while pressing the need for long-term contracts for experimental experts.

The responses from early-career scientists showed that further attention is needed to fulfil their aspirations and underscored the importance of understanding the mindsets of the collaboration’s different generations. The ATLAS Early Career Scientists Board took an active part in the analysis and proposed measures to strengthen its initiatives and its role in connecting young researchers with the wider community. Those adopted include allowing all individuals, not only PhD students, to share non-controversial internal results confidentially with job and grant panels, and deepening ties with the CERN Alumni network.

The responses underscored the importance of understanding the mindsets of the collaboration’s different generations

ATLAS strives to provide an equal-opportunity environment, and inclusion and diversity are among its founding values. Members rated its multicultural character highly, with 80% of respondents agreeing that it is inclusive and open, 16% being neutral, and 4% finding it non-inclusive and closed. Since 2017, ATLAS has appointed four collaboration members as diversity and inclusion contacts, and a dedicated equity, diversity and inclusion office has been created to enhance their work. Nevertheless, many collaborators were not fully aware of the CERN code of conduct, and the ATLAS management is now communicating the code more actively, including whom to approach in the event of a potential violation.

The strength within

Overall, the actions resulting from the survey were defined to strengthen communication within ATLAS and with external stakeholders, improve documentation and accessibility for greater efficiency and transparency, and ensure an effective transition from Phase-II construction to optimal Run 4 operations, across data-taking and analysis. They also seek to retain expertise, recognise diverse contributions, and continue promoting the CERN code of conduct and a working environment that supports mental health and wellbeing. The 37-item list concluded a broad, introspective exercise and delivered a roadmap for preparing ATLAS for its high-luminosity phase.

A journey worth sharing

Over the past few decades, relations between Big Science organisations (BSOs) and their industrial suppliers have changed substantially. Global circumstances have forced companies to focus on their regular markets and products, leaving less room for contracts that deviate from that core business. Deviation, however, is often what BSOs need, as the technologies their projects demand grow more complex. In addition, they often require large numbers of custom components that may be just purchased once, and only through formal tender procedures. Companies, therefore, often prefer to do business with other companies, where shared long-term interests and mutual trust are typically enough to strike a deal.

The challenge for BSOs is then to remain, or to become again, interesting to industry, with projects at a price both can afford. In achieving this, laboratories have more to offer than is generally appreciated. Companies that work with BSOs have been shown to benefit in their marketing, to expand and improve their product portfolios, and to attract and retain key personnel, because challenging specifications drive innovation.

Relations in the Big Science domain can take many forms, from the supply of standard services and commodities, through collaborative technical development, to the licensing of technology and know-how. No single model fits every company, and each arrangement must serve both sides. Industry, for its part, is indispensable at every scale, from standard cables and connectors to complete magnet and cryogenic systems, and in some areas it moves faster than the BSOs themselves. Design for manufacturability and design for cost, the arts of shaping a component for efficient and affordable production, are cases in point, and both matter more as systems get bigger. Industry’s experience should be brought into a project’s design phase as early as possible, especially where components are needed in large numbers and for long lifetimes.

On demanding and innovative projects, openness is what keeps industry on board

Given their status, BSOs must deal with industry within specific procurement rules. Still, the relationship in spirit must be closer to a partnership, in which communication is open, risk is shared, and both parties ultimately gain. Communication must flow freely within each organisation, between technical and commercial teams, and between the two partners. As the work proceeds, both must exchange detailed specifications and flag problems as they arise. On demanding and innovative projects, where sharing risk matters most, this openness is what keeps industry on board.

The stakes reach beyond the laboratories, of course. For countries participating in a BSO, the return on membership rests not only on the science but also on wider societal benefits (see The collider dividend). Chief among them at present is industrial growth and development, with new products, skills, partnerships, markets and intellectual property flowing back to the member states.

While the scientific return largely takes care of itself, through the institutes and universities involved in the experiments, national support for companies to connect with BSOs via industrial liaison officers (ILOs) varies significantly across countries. For the role to be effective, we must see challenges coming early, in time to identify potential suppliers or to help existing companies and incubators profit from the technologies being developed. ILOs, whether employed by a BSO or representing a country, are therefore central to building these partnerships.

Across their technical, management and commercial teams, BSOs must never lose sight of how fundamental long-term, mutually beneficial relationships with industry are. Their value exceeds limited, short-term financial gains, and savings won contract by contract can, over time, leave fewer companies willing to bid, to the detriment of science and industry alike.

Shared goals for colliders and climate

While particle physics accounts for only a small share of global emissions, its laboratories have long worked to reduce their footprint, showing how cutting-edge science can be pursued sustainably. The fifth Sustainable HEP conference, held online from 8 to 10 July, attracted more than 220 participants worldwide to take stock of that effort, and of the ingenious technologies meant to carry it forward.

Environmental impact

Archana Sharma (CERN) highlighted a fundamental shift in the questions asked of gaseous detectors in high-energy physics. In the 1970s, the challenge was to detect particles at all, while the LHC era demanded survival in extreme conditions. Today, minimal environmental impact has joined the list of priorities. Emissions from the LHC detector systems have already fallen over the past decade, thanks to gas recuperation, recirculation and the use of climate-friendly alternatives to traditional gas mixtures. Future facilities, Sharma stressed, should be designed for sustainability from the outset, rather than retrofitted later. Her point was echoed across the sessions. Contributions covered the operation of resistive-plate chambers in CMS and ATLAS, along with the EcoGas@GIF++ collaboration, which tests eco-friendly mixtures under LHC-like irradiation at CERN’s Gamma Irradiation Facility. Others explored material choices for future detectors, from high-strength copper alloys to greener shielding and cryogenics.

Future facilities should be designed for sustainability from the outset

Accelerators and other large-scale projects received similar attention. Ben Shepherd (STFC) reported on the activities of the Laboratory Directors Group’s sustainability working group, comparing the environmental impact of proposed colliders from construction to decommissioning. He described efforts to avoid environmental impacts where possible, reduce those that cannot be avoided, and compensate for the remainder, spanning civil engineering, procurement and energy optimisation. Examples include heat-recovery systems, energy-recovery linacs, and the growing use of high-temperature superconductors and permanent magnets.

Veronique Boisvert (Royal Holloway) briefed participants on the sustainability recommendations of the European Strategy for Particle Physics update, the roadmap defining Europe’s priorities for future particle-physics research and facilities. William van Sprolant (CvS énergies sàrl) presented the ULISSE Project, an exploratory large-scale initiative aiming at storing CERN’s summer waste heat in Lake Geneva for use in winter. Speakers presented initiatives across the field including Nikhef’s laboratory-wide roadmap, the iSAS programme on energy-efficient accelerating technology, sustainability work at the Electron–Ion Collider and life-cycle studies at LHCb. Other presentations covered methane recovery from livestock emissions and updates from the SC4RC computing conference.

Scientific computing came under the same scrutiny. Contributions included a particularly clear introduction to Fast Generative Simulation for HEP from Henry Day-Hall (DESY), alongside discussions of current and future efforts to shrink its carbon footprint by optimising the use of resources, improving simulation efficiency and adopting GPU-based systems, whose parallel architecture delivers more computation per watt. Participants heard of the power-efficient operation of large-scale computing facilities through the Worldwide LHC Computing Grid, which links centres around the world to process LHC data, carbon-aware computing schedules in ATLAS and the GreenPhysECS project, aimed at designing energy-efficient computing architectures for future facilities.

From physics to sustainability

As in previous editions, voices from beyond particle physics widened the view. Juan Pablo Cordero (University of York) presented open-source predictive models for transparent food policy-making. This year’s conference hosted a panel session featuring five speakers, who shared their experiences of transitioning from physics to sustainability. They cited adaptability, continuous learning and collaboration as the skills that helped them move into their new fields.

Lasting change requires ambitious policies and collective solutions

In his keynote speech, climate scientist Jagadish Shukla (George Mason University) discussed the science, politics and ethics of climate change. Those who have contributed least to global warming, he reminded participants, will suffer most and earliest. Yet he argued for hope, grounded in technological progress and shared effort. Lasting change requires ambitious policies and collective solutions, as the antidote to climate anxiety, he concluded, is climate action.

Physicists and artists entangle at CERN

From 11 to 18 January 2026, the SciArtDialogue Week brought 36 students, researchers, artists and educators to CERN’s IdeaSquare for a week of joint scientific and artistic work, marking the centenary of the quantum wave function. Organised by art@CMS/ORIGIN, an art-and-science education programme rooted in the CMS collaboration, the event drew support from institutions across Austria, Germany, the US and Australia.

The wave function entered physics in the first half of 1926, when Erwin Schrödinger reformulated quantum theory as a form of wave mechanics. Its meaning, though, was disputed from the beginning. Schrödinger himself took it to be a real wave of matter propagating through space. Within months, Max Born linked its squared modulus to the probabilities of measurement outcomes, and this settled the matter for all practical purposes. Yet whether the wave function describes the world itself or only our knowledge of it is still debated, and the week set scientists and artists to explore this tension together.

A comprehensive visit programme immersed participants in CERN’s unique scientific infrastructure. Based at IdeaSquare, they encountered large-scale experiments, gained insights into how data is collected and processed, reflected on the technological ingenuity behind particle physics and gathered important personal connections with the CERN scientific community. These experiences were complemented by in-depth contributions on quantum mechanics, the historical significance of Schrödinger’s work and the broader evolution of contemporary scientific paradigms.

ORF Ö1 journalist Susanna Niedermayr accompanied the whole workshop, documenting discussions among professors of fine arts, musicology and religious studies, and tracing how scientific concepts migrate into artistic practice. For the Austrian students, the week doubled as the start of a semester-long university course, in which they will further develop their projects. The resulting works, spanning sound, performance, visual media and conceptual installations, will be shown at the ORF festival in Graz, from 8 to 11 October. Whether art can bring an advanced scientific idea to a wider public is the question the initiative exists to test, and the answer will be on display there. The SciArtDialogue Week will return to CERN IdeaSquare in February 2027 to mark the centenary of the fifth Solvay Conference.

The best science stories and how they work

The Best Science Stories and How They Work

Science journalism has the difficult task of making complex ideas accessible without sacrificing the uncertainty, nuance and sometimes messiness that accompany scientific research. Yet when it succeeds, much of the work involved is invisible. Readers encounter the finished story, not the reporting decisions, discarded approaches, structural choices and conversations with sources that produced it. The Best Science Stories and How They Work turns its attention to this hidden process. Each of its 11 reprinted stories comes with an introduction and annotations by a fellow science journalist, followed by a conversation in which writer and annotator discuss how the piece came together. The result is both an anthology of contemporary science writing and an attempt to take that writing apart and see what makes it work.

A wide world of topics

The subjects are remarkably varied, encompassing medicine, climate change, genetics, conservation, mathematics and space exploration, and drawing on journalism originally published in outlets including Nature, Scientific American, The Atlantic, MIT Technology Review and The New York Times Magazine. Ed Yong’s “Fatigue can shatter a person”, for example, examines the debilitating experience of pathological fatigue, particularly in the context of long COVID, while Kendra Pierre-Louis investigates “How rising groundwater caused by climate change could devastate coastal communities”. Juxtaposing such different stories is crucial, as it shows how similar questions about evidence, explanation, narrative and human experience arise across scientific disciplines.

What makes the collection distinctive, however, is what happens around each article. Rather than asking readers simply to admire a successful piece of journalism, the annotations encourage them to notice its construction. Why does a story begin where it does? How is technical information introduced without interrupting the narrative? What makes a source compelling, and how should a journalist balance curiosity with scepticism? Such questions turn reading into a more active exercise. The conversations between writers and annotators add another layer by focusing attention on the decisions and challenges behind each piece.

A persuasive case for paying closer attention to how science stories are assembled

This emphasis on process makes the book relevant beyond aspiring science journalists. Communicating science is often described as a problem of translation: taking specialist knowledge and making it understandable to a non-specialist audience. The examples collected here suggest something much richer. Good communication also depends on judgement – what a reader needs to know, what can safely be omitted, where uncertainty matters and where explanation should give way to narrative. These decisions will be recognisable to any scientist who has tried to explain a result outside their immediate field.

There is inevitably a degree of artificiality in dismantling writing that was designed to be experienced as a whole. Not every reader will want to interrupt an engaging story to consider its underlying mechanics, and those looking primarily for physics or another particular discipline will find much of the collection removed from the subject of their interest. But that breadth is also one of the book’s strengths. Moving between very different flavours of science and storytelling, it resists the idea that successful science communication can be reduced to a single template. It offers instead something closer to a workshop built around examples: read the story, examine the choices behind it and consider what might be learnt.

The Best Science Stories and How They Work makes a persuasive case for paying closer attention to how science stories are assembled, as well as to what they say. To early-career journalists, it offers an opportunity to examine the working methods behind effective reporting. To scientists, it provides a reminder that making science understandable involves more than simplifying terminology.

François Englert 1932–2026

François Englert died on 18 June in Uccle, in the Brussels region, aged 93. Beyond his major contributions to fundamental physics, he had a profound, if discreet, influence on the Belgian scientific community.

He was born on 6 November 1932 in Etterbeek (Brussels), to a family of Jewish immigrants from Poland. During World War II, François and his older brother Marc became enfants cachés – hidden children – finding refuge in the countryside at great risk to those who sheltered them. For a child so young, it was a traumatic experience, which François long kept to himself. After the war, he enrolled at the Université Libre de Bruxelles (ULB) in the Faculty of Applied Sciences, a frequent choice at the time, as it guaranteed employment and claimed to offer the same training as a physics degree. After graduating in 1955 he switched to physics, quickly completing a licence in 1958 and a PhD, under the supervision of Jules Géhéniau, the following year.

A turning point in his career came with a postdoctoral stay at Cornell University, where Robert Brout, at first his adviser, became a lifelong colleague. He came back to ULB in 1961, as a lecturer in general physics, and Robert soon followed him. Only later, in 1980, would they formally found the Theoretical Physics group – a generic name chosen to avoid dissecting physics into separate specialities.

Open culture

From Cornell, they had brought back an informal culture: the door was always open to anyone who wanted to discuss physics. As students, we were completely immersed in the research, spending whole afternoons with the two leaders in a sort of musical-chairs brainstorming at the blackboard. They also made sure that a permanent position could be considered only after a postdoctoral stay abroad, an attitude that eventually spread to other departments, reversing a long tradition of internal recruitment.

In the early 1960s, François and Robert were looking for a way to formulate short-distance interactions in the formalism of quantum field theory (QFT). Gauge-invariant QFT was known to describe quantum electrodynamics, but dealt only with massless gauge bosons and hence long-distance interactions. The mechanism they found was submitted to Physical Review Letters in June 1964, in a paper that showed diagrammatically how gauge bosons could acquire mass. Independently, in July, Peter Higgs approached the problem focusing on the elimination of unwanted Goldstone bosons, and included the mass of the gauge bosons in a later paper.

That short paper by François and Robert was in fact remarkably complete: it included the basic spontaneous symmetry breaking by a fundamental scalar field, as is now standard, but also a dynamical approach assuming fermion condensates, and it covered the non-abelian case. The mechanism also opened the way to the proof of the renormalisability of the theory. At the time, both the strong and the weak interactions were candidates for such symmetry breaking, but a concrete realisation awaited a 1967 paper by Steven Weinberg. A different mechanism, confinement, was eventually shown to operate in strong interactions.

François and Robert soon turned their attention to cosmology, first joined by Edgard Gunzig, then by Philippe Spindel and eventually by the whole Brussels group – an exceptional case, as they had insisted that its members operate as independent individuals. One puzzle, in particular, drew them. In an expanding universe, regions thought never to have been in causal contact show almost the same temperature in the cosmic microwave background, the fossil radiation of the Big Bang. Their explanation relied on a fast initial expansion phase, a scenario they called the “causal universe”. Here, too, they were precursors. François’s curiosity extended to a wide variety of topics, with more interest in finding mechanisms than in a tedious zoology of nature. These ranged from generating the spacetime metric out of a fractal structure to the classification of monopoles and even the structure of viruses!

While François and Robert played a formative role in the Belgian physics community, François never mentioned his role in the student revolts at ULB in 1968, since the structures that emerged from them had fallen short of his hopes. In fact, he kept clear of institutional academic roles altogether. His influence was felt otherwise. Formal recognition, too, was long in coming. It began with the Gravity Research Foundation award (1978), followed by the Francqui Prize (1982), the European Physical Society Prize (1997), the Wolf Prize (2004) and the Sakurai Prize (2010). In 2013 came the Prince of Asturias Award and the Nobel Prize, awarded to François and Peter Higgs, Robert Brout having died in 2011. King Albert II made François a baron in the same year, and he was also appointed professor at Tel Aviv University.

A point of reference

It must be realised that, by the time of François’s and Robert’s seminal paper, QFT itself had fallen out of fashion. Despite its success in quantum electrodynamics, the framework could not be applied to short-distance interactions, and many preferred more holistic approaches, such as the unitary S-matrix. Interest returned progressively as spontaneous symmetry breaking gained acceptance, a shift that can be followed in the paper’s own citation curve, and François and Robert embarked on an inter-university series of lectures and seminars. Despite the philosophical and linguistic differences between the universities, this seeded or cemented the contacts between the theoretical physics groups of Brussels, Leuven and Louvain-la-Neuve. The effort made them a point of reference for Belgian physics.

Interestingly, this path had been trodden before them by Monsignor Georges Lemaître, father of the Big Bang, who visited ULB frequently. To celebrate these unifying efforts, the Belgian Senate, later joined by the Brussels Region, encouraged the formation of the Brout–Englert–Lemaître (BEL) Centre, common to ULB, the Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB), the Université Catholique de Louvain (UCLouvain) and the Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (KU Leuven).

Guenakh Mitselmakher 1945–2026

Guenakh Mitselmakher, an experimental high-energy physicist of international stature, passed away on 28 January at the age of 80. He was born on 5 December 1945 in Vilnius, Lithuania. After graduating from Moscow State University in 1968, Guenakh started his professional career at the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (JINR) in Dubna, Russia. He often recalled that his mentor Bruno Pontecorvo made the largest impact on his scientific vision and “physics taste”.

For his PhD, he joined a collaboration of four that was designing an experiment to search for the charged-lepton flavour violating decay μ → 3e. The result, published in 1976, improved on the best previous limit by two orders of magnitude. Next, he took part in the first measurement of the charged-pion radius at the Serpukhov accelerator, published in 1974. He then proposed and co-led an experiment that yielded the first measurements of the pion’s polarisability and the γ → 3π coupling in 1983 and 1986, respectively. In the mid-1980s, he and his group joined the DELPHI experiment at LEP. Guenakh co-led the construction of the DELPHI hadron calorimeter and made critical contributions to the measurement of the number of light neutrinos coupling to the Z boson. To this end, he co-initiated the collaboration of theorists and experimentalists that developed the analysis framework later known as ZFITTER.

Guenakh moved to the US in 1991, to join the Superconducting Super Collider (SSC) laboratory in Texas. After the closure of the SSC, in 1993, and having worked briefly at Fermilab, he joined the University of Florida (UF) physics department in 1995. There, he spearheaded a vigorous experimental hadron-collider programme, building a group that at its peak counted seven faculty and more than 40 members, including students, postdocs and engineers. Together they made major contributions to the CDF experiment at Fermilab and to the CMS experiment at CERN, where Guenakh led the design and construction of the endcap muon system.

In both experiments, the UF group held leading roles in the physics programme, most notably in the Higgs-boson discovery in 2012, in precision measurements of the new particle’s properties, and in many searches for new physics. Among them, the recent search for the charged-lepton flavour violating decay τ → 3μ echoes Guenakh’s research from the early years of his career. He was also the driving force behind UF joining the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) in 1996, where the group contributed prominently to the design and construction of the apparatus and to data analysis. Indeed, the first gravitational-wave event, in 2015, was initially identified by coherent WaveBurst, a real-time analysis algorithm conceived in a 2008 paper that Guenakh co-authored.

Guenakh Mitselmakher was a relentless advocate for the pursuit of physics of pivotal significance. His scientific legacy will persist through the many scientists he mentored during his career.

George Kalmus 1935–2026

It is with great sadness that we learned George Kalmus passed away on 27 May, at the age of 91. George had a long and distinguished career in particle physics, which took him from the early days of bubble chambers to the LHC and beyond.

Born in Beočin, Yugoslavia, on 21 April 1935, George moved to London with his family in 1939. He obtained his physics degrees at University College London (UCL), gaining his PhD in 1959 with the pioneering study “Physical properties of bubble chambers”. As a research assistant at UCL, he was responsible for the design and specification of the magnet for the British Heavy Liquid Bubble Chamber. He also studied semileptonic decays of Λ hyperons with UCL colleagues and a group at the Lawrence Radiation Laboratory in Berkeley, later the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory (LBL), using their 30-inch heavy liquid chamber.

From 1962 to 1967, apart from one year back at UCL, he worked at LBL as a research assistant, studying semileptonic Λ decays and all aspects of K+ meson decays, especially the rare semileptonic four-body K+e4 channel. He became a tenured senior physicist at LBL in 1967, switching to the study of hadron resonances using K– and π+ beams.

In 1972, George returned to Europe to lead the bubble-chamber group at the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory (RAL). His large group participated in various collaborations, with George himself proposing and working on K–p and K0Lp experiments in the 2 m hydrogen bubble chamber at CERN.

Following the discovery of open charm in 1976, he proposed and led a major experiment to investigate direct electron production by hadrons using a track-sensitive target in the Big European Bubble Chamber at CERN. He subsequently led a collaboration at the SLAC Hybrid Facility, where he instigated the addition of a high-resolution camera. This was crucial to the successful measurement, in 1982, of the decays of D mesons produced by 20 GeV photons in the 1 m hydrogen bubble chamber. His exploitation of bubble chambers and work on kaon and charm physics contributed to his election as fellow of the Royal Society in 1988.

George went on to establish the UK collaboration working on DELPHI at CERN’s LEP collider, where he applied his formidable expertise to all aspects of the experiment: design, realisation and analysis. He led RAL’s involvement in the construction of the superconducting solenoid – at the time the largest in the world – and pushed for the addition of a silicon microvertex detector, one of the first at LEP. He was elected deputy spokesman for DELPHI and chaired its collaboration board from 1986 to 1993.

George was director of RAL’s Particle Physics Department from 1986 to 1997, with wide-ranging responsibilities for the whole of the UK’s particle-physics programme, latterly including the preparation of the LHC experiments. He was appointed to CERN’s Scientific Policy Committee from 1990 to 1997 – a time that saw the approval of the LHC – and chaired it from 1999 to 2001.

In 1998 George returned to his earlier interest in ultra-rare kaon decays by joining the NA48 experiment at CERN. He retired from RAL in 2000, but not from physics, joining the ZEPLIN-III experiment to search for dark matter in the Boulby Underground Laboratory in Yorkshire, UK.

George had a special combination of scientific ability, integrity and human skills, all greatly appreciated by those who knew and worked with him. He helped many careers and led UK particle physics with a sure hand through sometimes tempestuous waters for more than a decade. We owe him a great deal. He was survived by his brother, Peter, professor at Queen Mary University of London, his three daughters and his grandchildren. Our deepest sympathy goes to the whole family.

• We are very saddened to have learned that Peter Kalmus passed away on 2 August. A full obituary will appear in a later edition of CERN Courier.

Norman McCubbin 1948–2026

To the shock of family, colleagues and friends, Norman McCubbin died suddenly at his home in Oxford on 22 June. His long and distinguished career included vital roles in UK particle physics and at CERN.

Norman was born in north London on 27 June 1948, the eldest of three sons. His family later left Leicester for Kenya, where Norman attended Kenton College in Nairobi. He then boarded at the prestigious Repton School in Derbyshire, to which he jokingly ascribed his success in winning ballot tickets to England test cricket matches. He attended New College, University of Oxford, achieving a first-class honours degree and a doctorate. His thesis contained an analysis of K–p interactions in the CERN 2 m bubble chamber.

Norman moved to CERN as a Lancaster postdoc, working on the CHLM experiment at the Intersecting Storage Rings. After joining the Rutherford Appleton Laboratory (RAL) as a postdoc in 1976, he moved to the British–French–Scandinavian collaboration on the Wide-Angle Spectrometer and then the Axial Field Spectrometer, where he worked on the world’s first uranium compensating calorimeter. After getting tenure at RAL, Norman joined the HELIOS fixed-target heavy-ion experiment, of which he became spokesperson.

He was involved in the early stages of the ZEUS experiment at DESY, becoming leader of the RAL ZEUS group in 1990, and managed a large group of capable technical staff and research associates who worked on the construction and commissioning of the central tracking detector. Norman also played an important role in developing the experiment’s software and held senior positions, including simulation coordinator. He remained closely involved throughout ZEUS’s running.

As ZEUS matured, he began to work on ATLAS, again leading the development of the software. He was computing coordinator from 1999 to 2003, steering the decision on computing language with typically consummate tact. His advice was greatly valued by successive ATLAS spokespersons, who gave him numerous important responsibilities, including chairing the committee that in 2007 recommended task-sharing algorithms and criteria for ATLAS membership, authorship and financial contributions. He was assiduous in employing his exceptional command of English to correct and polish ATLAS papers, and maintained his keen interest in heavy ions as an expert within ATLAS.

Norman was a leader of UK particle physics, becoming first division leader and, from 2007, director of RAL’s Particle Physics Department, while gaining the admiration and respect of all who worked with him. After officially retiring from RAL in 2012, Norman continued to contribute to ATLAS and taught physics to undergraduates at St Anne’s College, Oxford. He inspired many generations of students and was an extremely popular tutor, relishing the core subjects of thermodynamics, statistical mechanics, relativity and symmetries.

Norman McCubbin was a Renaissance man, learned but never pedantic, broad in interests and expertise. He loved cricket and golf, music and current affairs. He was an exceptional physicist, publishing both cutting-edge particle-physics papers and articles on the history of physics. He will be greatly missed by his family and his many colleagues and friends.

• A fund has been set up in Norman’s memory to endow an annual prize for the best physics student at the college at which he taught, St. Anne’s Oxford.

bright-rec iop pub iop-science physcis connect