A team at the National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory (NSCL) at Michigan State University has developed a new experimental technique for measuring (p, n) charge-exchange reactions at intermediate energies (˜100 MeV/nucleon) on rare isotopes. The main virtue of the technique is that it can be applied to study the isovector response of rare isotopes of any mass and up to high excitation energies. Previously, charge-exchange experiments with rare isotopes were restricted to light isotopes and final states at low excitation-energies.
The new technique has been applied first to study Gamow-Teller (GT) transitions from 56Ni – an important case for modelling electron-capture rates of interest for the late evolution of core-collapse and thermonuclear supernovae (Sasano et al. 2011 and Langanke 2011). Nuclear charge-exchange reactions at intermediate energies have long been used to study the spin-isospin response of stable nuclei and weak reaction rates, in particular for astrophysical purposes.
To study the (p, n) reaction on the rare nickel isotope, the experiment was performed in inverse kinematics. A beam of 56Ni particles at 110 MeV/u, produced by fast-fragmentation of 58Ni particles from the NSCL coupled-cyclotron facility on a thick production target, was directed at a liquid hydrogen target, which provided the proton “probe”. The newly constructed Low-Energy Neutron Detector Array detected recoil neutrons, allowing the excitation energy of the 56Cu reaction product and the centre-of-mass scattering angle to be deduced by measuring the neutron angle and energy. The S800 spectrograph detected heavy fragments (56Cu, or one of its decay products). After isolating the ΔL=0 components of the excitation-energy spectrum via their distinct forward-peaked angular distribution, the team was able to extract the GT transition strength, using the well established proportionality between the differential cross-section at vanishing momentum transfer and the GT strength.
The figure shows the extracted GT strength as a function of excitation energy and the comparison with two shell-model calculations based on different Hamiltonians. Because isospin symmetry-breaking effects are small and 56Ni has isospin I=0, the strength distribution for the 56Ni→56Cu reaction is nearly identical to that for the 56Ni→56Co reaction. The latter is of relevance for electron captures in stellar environments, while 56Ni plays a central role in the studies of weak reaction rates for supernovae. By benchmarking and improving the shell-model calculations for the N=Z=28 nucleus 56Ni, more reliable calculations of electron-capture rates for many nuclei in the iron group will be possible.
The quark model of hadron classification proposed by Murray Gell-Mann and George Zweig in 1964 motivated the opinion that a new state of matter, namely strongly interacting matter composed of subhadronic constituents, may exist. Soon thereafter, quantum chromodynamics (QCD) was formulated as the theory of strong interactions, with quarks and gluons as elementary constituents. As a natural consequence, the existence of a state of quasi-free quarks and gluons – the QCD quark–gluon plasma (QGP) – was suggested by Edward Shuryak in 1975. These events, together with the rapid development of particle-accelerator and detector techniques, mark the beginning of the experimental search for this hypothetical, subhadronic form of matter in nature.
First indications
The experimental efforts received a boost from the first acceleration of oxygen and sulphur nuclei at CERN’s Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS) in 1986 (√sNN ≈ 20 GeV) and of lead nuclei in 1994 (√sNN ≈ 17 GeV). Measurements from an array of experiments were surprisingly well described by statistical and hydrodynamical models. They indicated that the created system of strongly interacting particles is close to at least local equilibrium (Heinz and Jacob 2000). Thus, a necessary condition for QGP creation in heavy-ion collisions was found to be fulfilled. The “only” remaining problem was the identification of unique experimental signatures of QGP.
The strategy is clear: look for a rapid change of energy dependence of hadron production properties.
Unfortunately, precise quantitative predictions are currently impossible to calculate within QCD and predictions of phenomenological models suffer from large uncertainties. Therefore, the results of the measurements were only suggestive of the production of QGP in heavy-ion collisions at the top SPS energy. The same situation persisted at the top energies of Brookhaven’s Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) and seems to be repeated at the LHC. Despite many arguments in favour of the creation of QGP at these energies, its discovery cannot be claimed from these data alone.
A different strategy for identifying the creation of QGP was followed by the NA49 experiment at the SPS and is now being continued by its successor NA61/SHINE, as well as by the STAR experiment at RHIC. The idea is to measure quantities that are sensitive to the state of strongly interacting matter as a function of collision energy in, for example, central lead–lead collisions.
The reasoning is based on simple arguments. First, the energy density of matter created at the early stage of heavy-ion collisions increases monotonically with collision energy. Thus, if two phases of matter exist, the low-energy density phase is created in collisions at low energies and the high-energy density phase in collisions at high energies. Second, the properties of both phases differ significantly, with some of the differences surviving until the freeze-out to hadrons and so can be measured in experiments. The search strategy is therefore clear: look for a rapid change of the energy dependence of hadron production properties that are sensitive to QGP, because these will signal the transition to the new state of matter and indicate its existence.
This strategy, and the corresponding NA49 energy-scan programme, were motivated in particular by a statistical model of the early stage of nucleus–nucleus collisions (Gazdzicki and Gorenstein 1999). It predicted that the onset of deconfinement should lead to rapid changes of the collision-energy dependence of bulk properties of produced hadrons, all appearing in a common energy domain. Data from 1999 to 2002 on central Pb+Pb collisions at 20A, 30A, 40A, 80A and 158A GeV were recorded and the predicted features were observed at low SPS energies.
An independent verification of NA49’s discovery is vital and calls for further measurements in the SPS energy range. Two new experimental programmes are already in operation: the ion programme of NA61/SHINE at the SPS; and the beam-energy scan at RHIC. Elsewhere, the construction of the Nuclotron-based Ion Collider at JINR, Dubna, is in preparation. The basic goals of this experimental effort are the confirmation and the study of the details of the onset of deconfinement and the investigation of the transition line between the two phases of strongly interacting matter. In particular, the discovery of the hypothesized second-order critical end-point would be a milestone in uncovering properties of strongly interacting matter.
Four pointers
Last year rich data from the RHIC beam-energy scan programme were released (Kumar 2011, Mohanty 2011). Furthermore, the first results from Pb+Pb collisions at the LHC were revealed (Schukraft et al. 2011, Toia et al. 2011). It is therefore time to review the status of the observation of the onset of deconfinement. The plots in figure 1 summarize relevant results that became available in June 2011. They show the energy dependence of four hadron-production properties measured in central Pb+Pb (Au+Au) collisions, which reveal structures referred to as the “horn”, “kink”, “step” and “dale” – all located in the SPS energy range.
The horn. The most dramatic change of the energy dependence is seen for the ratio of yields of kaons and pions (figure 1a). The steep threshold rise of the ratio characteristic for confined matter changes at high energy into a constant value at the level expected for deconfined matter. In the transition region (at low SPS energies) a sharp maximum is observed, caused by the higher production ratio of strangeness-to-entropy in confined matter than in deconfined matter.
The kink. Most particles produced in high-energy interactions are pions. Thus, pions carry basic information on the entropy created in the collisions. On the other hand, entropy production depends on the form of matter present at the early stage of collisions. Deconfined matter is expected to lead to a final state with higher entropy than confined matter. Consequently, the entropy increase at the onset of deconfinement is expected to lead to a steeper increase with collision energy of the pion yield per participating nucleon. This effect is observed for central Pb+Pb collisions (figure 1b). When passing through low SPS energies, the slope of the rise in the ratio <π>/<NP> with the Fermi energy measure F ≈ √√sNN increases by a factor of about 1.3. Within the statistical model of the early stage, this corresponds to an increase of the effective number of degrees of freedom by a factor of about 3.
The step. The experimental results on the energy dependence of the inverse slope parameter, T, of K– transverse-mass spectra for central Pb+Pb (Au+Au) collisions are shown in figure 1c. The striking features of these data can be summarized and interpreted as follows (Gorenstein et al. 2003). The T parameter increases strongly with collision energy up to low SPS energies, where the creation of confined matter at the early stage of the collisions takes place. In a pure phase, increasing collision energy leads to an increase of the early-stage temperature and pressure. Consequently the transverse momenta of produced hadrons, measured by the inverse slope parameter, increase with collision energy. This rise is followed by a region of approximately constant value of the T parameter in the SPS energy range, where the transition between confined and deconfined matter with the creation of a mixed phase is located. The resulting softening of the equation of state “suppresses” the hydrodynamical transverse expansion and leads to the observed plateau or even a minimum structure in the energy dependence of the T parameter. At higher energies (RHIC data), T again increases with collision energy. The equation of state at the early stage again becomes stiff and the early-stage pressure increases with collision energy, resulting in a resumed increase of T.
The dale. As discussed above, a weakening of the transverse expansion is expected to result from the onset of deconfinement because of the softening of the equation of state at the early stage. Clearly, the latter should also weaken the longitudinal expansion (Petersen and Bleicher 2006). This expectation is confirmed in figure 1d, where the width of the π– rapidity spectra in central Pb+Pb collisions relative to the prediction of ideal Landau hydrodynamics is plotted as a function of the collision energy. In fact, the ratio has a clear minimum at low SPS energies.
A smooth evolution is observed between the top SPS energy and the current energy of the LHC.
The results shown in figure 1 include new results on central Pb+Pb collisions at the LHC and data on central Au+Au collisions from the RHIC beam-energy scan. The RHIC results confirm the NA49 measurements at the onset energies while the LHC data demonstrate that the energy dependence of hadron-production properties shows rapid changes only at low SPS energies. A smooth evolution is observed between the top SPS energy (17.2 GeV) and the current energy of the LHC (2.76 TeV). This strongly supports the interpretation of the NA49 structures as arising from the onset of deconfinement. Above the onset energy only a smooth change of the QGP properties with increasing collision energy is expected.
The first LHC data thus confirm the following expected effects:
• an approximate energy independence of the K+/π+ ratio above the top SPS energy (figure 1a);
• a linear increase of the pion yield per participant with F ≈ √√sNN with the slope defined by the top SPS data (figure 1b);
• a monotonic increase of the kaon inverse-slope parameter with energy above the top SPS energy (figure 1c).
The width of the π– rapidity spectra in central Pb+Pb collisions should increase continuously from the top SPS energies to the LHC energies, as predicted by ideal gas Landau hydrodynamics. LHC data on rapidity spectra are required to verify this expectation.
The NA61/SHINE experiment
The confirmation of the NA49 measurements and their interpretation in terms of the onset of deconfinement by the new LHC and RHIC data strengthen the arguments for the NA61/SHINE experiment, which will use secondary proton and Be, as well as primary Ar and Xe beams in the SPS beam momentum range (13A–158A GeV/c). The basic components of the NA61 detector were inherited from NA49. Several important upgrades – in particular, the new and faster read-out of the time-projection chambers, the new, state-of-the-art resolution Projectile Spectator Detector and the installation of background-reducing helium beam pipes – allow the collection of data of high statistical and systematic accuracy. In parallel to the ion programme, the NA61/SHINE experiment is also making precision measurements of hadron production in proton- and pion-nucleus collisions for the Pierre Auger Observatory’s studies of cosmic rays and the T2K long-baseline neutrino experiment.
NA61 has already begun a two-dimensional scan in collision energy and the size of the colliding nuclei (figure 2). Data on proton–proton interactions at six collision energies were recorded in 2009–2011 and a successful test of secondary ion beams took place in 2010. The first physics run with secondary Be beams came in November/December 2011. Most important for the programme are runs with primary Ar and Xe beams, expected for 2014 and 2015, respectively. The collaboration between CERN and the iThemba Laboratory in South Africa is ensuring a timely optimization of the ion-source parameters. This all adds up to a future where the results from NA61 will allow a detailed study of the properties of the onset of deconfinement and a systematic search for the critical point of strongly interacting matter.
Located under 1700 m of rock in the Modane Underground Laboratory (LSM) at the middle of the Fréjus Rail Tunnel, the NEMO 3 experiment was designed to search for neutrinoless double beta decay, with the aim of discovering the nature of the neutrino – whether it is a Majorana or Dirac particle – and measuring its mass. The experiment ran for seven years before it finally stopped taking data in January 2010. While the sought-after decay mode remained elusive, NEMO 3 nevertheless made impressive headway in the study of double beta decay, providing new limits on a number of processes beyond the Standard Model.
Standard double beta decay (ββ2ν) involves the simultaneous disintegration of two neutrons in a nucleus into two protons with the emission of two electrons accompanied by two antineutrinos, (A,Z) → (A,Z+2) + 2e– +2ν. It is a second-order Standard Model process and for it to occur the transition to the intermediate nucleus accessible by normal beta decay, (A,Z) → (A,Z+1) + e– + ν, must be forbidden by conservation of either energy or angular momentum. In nature, there are 70 isotopes that can decay by ββ2ν and experiments have observed this process in 10 of these, with half-lives ranging from 1018 to 1021 years. However, ββ2ν decay is not sensitive to the nature or mass of the neutrino, unlike double beta decay with no emitted neutrinos (ββ0ν). This process, (A,Z) → (A,Z+2) + 2e–, is forbidden by the Standard Model electroweak interaction because it violates the conservation of lepton number (ΔL = 2). Such a decay can occur only if the neutrino is a Majorana particle (a fermion that is its own antiparticle). Non-Standard Model processes that can lead to ββ0ν decay include the exchange of a light neutrino, in which case the inverse of the ββ0ν half-life depends on the square of the effective neutrino mass. Other possible processes involve a right-handed neutrino current, a Majoron coupling or supersymmetric particle exchange.
The experimental signature for double beta-decay processes appears in the sum of the energy of the two electrons. For ββ0ν decay, this would have a peak at the Qββ transition energy (typically 2–4 MeV), while for ββ2ν decay it takes the form of a continuous spectrum from zero to Qββ. There are also two other observables: the angular distribution between the two electrons and the individual energy of the electrons. These two variables can distinguish which process is responsible for ββ0ν decay, if it is observed.
The NEMO collaboration – where NEMO stands for the Neutrino Ettore Majorana Observatory – has been working on ββ0ν decay since 1989. The design of the NEMO 3 detector, which evolved from two prototypes, NEMO 1 and NEMO 2, began in 1994 and construction started three years later. The method uses a number of thin source foils of enriched double beta-decay emitters surrounded by two tracking volumes and a calorimeter.
The challenge for any search for ββ0ν decay is the control of the backgrounds from cosmic rays, natural radioactivity, neutrons and radon. The background comes from any particle interactions or radioactive decays that can produce two electrons in the source foils. Because the signal level is so low, even third- and fourth-order processes can be a problem. Cosmic rays are suppressed by installing the experiment in a deep underground laboratory, as at the LSM. Natural radioactivity is reduced by material selection and purification of the source isotopes: the source foils in NEMO 3 had a radioactivity level a million times less than the natural level of radioactivity (around 100 Bq/kg). Neutrons and high-energy γ-rays are suppressed by specially designed and adapted shielding.
The NEMO 3 detector
The principle of NEMO 3 was to detect the two emitted electrons and to measure their energy as well as their angular distribution and their individual energies. The identification of the electrons reduces drastically the background compared with the calorimetric techniques of other experiments. The price of this advantage is a rather modest energy resolution, partly as a result of the electron’s energy loss in the source foils. However, the experimental sensitivity for ββ0ν depends on the product of the energy resolution and the number of background events. The source foils in NEMO 3 had a thickness of around 100 μm, which corresponded to a compromise between the amount of radioactive isotope and the electrons’ energy losses.
Another advantage of this experimental technique is the possibility of using different isotopes. The double beta-decay source inside NEMO 3 had a total mass of 10 kg, which was shared as follows: 6.914 kg of 100Mo, 0.932 kg of 82Se, 0.405 kg of 116Cd, 0.454 kg of 130Te, 37.0 g of 150Nd, 9.4 g of 96Zr and 7.0 g of 48Ca. These isotopes were enriched in Russia. In addition, two ultrapure sources of copper (0.621 kg) and natural tellurium (0.491 kg) were used to measure the external background. It is the first time that a detector has measured seven different double beta-decay emitters at the same time.
The NEMO 3 detector was made of 20 identical sectors. The tracking volume consisted of 8000 drift chambers working in Geiger mode. The volume was filled with a mixture of helium, 4% alcohol, 1% argon and a few parts per million of water to ensure the stable behaviour of the chamber. Electrons could be tracked with energy down to 100 keV with an efficiency of greater than 99%.The calorimeter was made of 2000 plastic scintillators coupled to low-radioactivity Hamamatsu phototubes. The choice of plastic scintillator was driven by the low Z to reduce back scattering, the low radioactivity and the cost. The calorimeter allowed measurements of both the energy (σ=3.6% at 3 MeV) and the time of flight (σ= 300 ps at 1 MeV).
A coil created a magnetic field of 0.003 T to enable the identification of the sign of the electrons. The shielding was made of 20 cm of iron to reduce γ-ray background and 30 cm of water to reduce the neutron background. A tent flushed with air containing just 15 mBq/m3 of radon surrounded the whole detector.
The unique feature of the NEMO 3 experiment was its ability to identify electrons, positrons, γ-rays and delayed α-particles. Figure 2 shows a typical double beta-decay event in NEMO 3 with two electrons emitted from a source foil, with the track curvature in the magnetic field identifying the charge and the struck scintillator blocks measuring the energy and the time of flight. The timing is important to distinguish a background electron crossing the detector (Δt=4 ns) from two electrons coming from a source foil (Δt=0 ns).
The experiment has measured the background through various analysis channels: single e–, e–+γ, e+α, e–+α+γ, e–+γ+γ, e–+e+ and so on. This allows measurements to be made of the actual backgrounds from residual contamination of the source foils as well as from the surrounding materials. Figure 3 demonstrates the ability of the experiment to identify the many sources of external background in the e–γ channel (as an example) for the 100Mo source foil.
NEMO 3 has produced an impressive list of results. The main result is, of course, related to the search for ββ0ν decay. Figure 4 shows the sum of the electron energy for 7 kg of 100Mo after 4.5 years of data-taking, zoomed into the region where the signal for ββ0ν decay is expected. The measurement of all of the kinematic parameters and the identification of all of the sources of background allows a 3D likelihood analysis to be performed. The result is a limit on the half-life of T1/2 > 1×1024 years, corresponding to a neutrino mass limit <mν> < 0.3–0.9 eV. The range corresponds to the spread associated with the different nuclear matrix-element calculations that must be used to extract the effective neutrino mass. This limit obtained with 7 kg of 100Mo is one of the best limits, together with the result of <mν> <0.3 – 0.7 eV from the Cuoricino experiment (12 kg of 130Te) and of <mν> < 0.3–1.0 eV from the Heidelberg-Moscow experiment (11 kg of 76Ge).
One possible scenario for ββ0ν involves the emission of the Majoron, the hypothetical massless boson associated with the spontaneous breaking of baryon-number minus lepton-number (B-L) symmetry. NEMO 3 has obtained the best limit so far for the Majoron-neutrino coupling, with gM < (0.4–1.8) × 10–4. The experiment has also set a limit on the λ parameter in models where a right-handed current exists for neutrinos, with λ < 1.4 × 10–6. These limits were obtained by analysing the angular distributions of the decay electrons and they are therefore unique to NEMO 3.
In addition, NEMO 3 has measured the half-lives for seven ββ2ν decays, providing a high-precision test of the Standard Model and nuclear data that can be used in theoretical calculations. In seven years, more than 700,000 events were recorded for ββ2ν emission from 100Mo. Figure 5 shows the energy spectrum, angular distribution and single energies measured for 100Mo. The first direct detection of ββ2ν decay to the 0+ excited state has also been measured for this nucleus and the first limit on the bosonic component of the neutrino has been obtained.
The NEMO 3 detector has demonstrated a powerful method for searching for neutrinoless double beta decay, with the unique capability of measuring all kinematic parameters of the decay. The next step for the NEMO collaboration is to build the SuperNEMO detector, which will accommodate 100 kg of source foil (82Se, 150Nd or 48Ca) to reach a sensitivity of 50 meV on the effective mass of the neutrino. A demonstrator module is under construction in several laboratories around the world and will start operation in 2013 in the LSM, with 7 kg of 82Se. The main improvement in this larger detector over NEMO 3 will be the energy resolution (σ=1.7% at 3 MeV) and the reduction of the background by a factor of 10. This demonstrator will improve the current limit on the effective neutrino mass and is expected to reach the goal of a zero-background experiment for 7 kg of source and two years of data-taking, which has never been done before. With this demonstration, the collaboration will be ready to build more Super NEMO modules up to the maximum source mass possible.
• The NEMO and SuperNEMO collaboration is formed by laboratories from France, the UK, Russia, the US, Japan, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Ukraine, Chile and Korea. The LSM is operated by the CNRS and the CEA.
The ALICE collaboration has measured the production of baryons containing two or three strange quarks in lead–lead collisions at the LHC, at an energy of 2.76 TeV per nucleon pair, nearly 14 times larger than that obtained previously at Brookhaven’s Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC). The yields and transverse-momentum spectra of multi-strange baryons and antibaryons in heavy-ion collisions are important in characterizing the evolution of the hot-matter created, as it passes from the strange quarks and antiquarks of the early partonic stages to the subsequent hadronization.
The collaboration identified multi-strange baryons mainly by a topological method, looking for their weak-decay products originating from secondary vertices well separated from the main interaction vertex. The researchers also exploited particle identification via specific energy loss in the time projection chamber (TPC). For example, the Ω– baryon (consisting of three strange quarks) decays into a negative K meson and a neutral Λ baryon, which in turn decays into a proton and a negative π meson. A peak in the invariant mass spectrum of all (Λ, K–) combinations provides a clearly identifiable signal (figure 1).
Good momentum resolution and a precise secondary-vertex reconstruction were essential for this result. A key element was the excellent performance of the main tracking detectors in ALICE’s central barrel – the TPC and the internal tracking system (ITS) – in the challenging environment of central (head-on) lead–lead collisions.
The data were analysed in transverse momentum intervals up to 6–9 GeV/c for the doubly-strange baryons (Ξ– and charge conjugate separately) and 6–8 GeV/c for the triply-strange baryons (Ω– and charge conjugate separately), made possible by the examination of 30 million minimum-bias nuclear interaction candidate events. In addition, the centrality of the selected events was determined from signals collected in two scintillator hodoscopes at backward and forward rapidities (K Aamodt et al. 2011). This allowed the analysis to be repeated in four different centrality intervals, from the 0–20% most central (almost head-on) collisions to the 60–90% peripheral collisions, in order to compare with previous results at RHIC. Figure 2 shows the resulting transverse-momentum spectra, fully corrected for detector acceptance and efficiency; it also shows clearly how multi-strange baryon production increases with the centrality of the collision at LHC energy. The results were presented at the recent conference on Strangeness in Quark Matter (Strangeness and heavy flavours in Krakow).
Previous experiments at CERN’s Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS) and at RHIC obtained multi-strange baryon spectra and yields in 17 GeV lead–lead and 200 GeV gold–gold collisions, respectively. The ALICE experiment not only finds higher yields in lead–lead collisions at the LHC energy, but also finds that the enhancement with respect to proton–proton collisions is greater for the Ω than for the Ξ, confirming the trend observed at both SPS and RHIC. Moreover, the enhancement with respect to proton–proton data increases with the centrality of the collision, in a similar way to previous observations.
Supersymmetry (SUSY) is still one of the strong candidates for physics beyond the Standard Model that could be detected in proton–proton collisions at the LHC. It could solve many of the outstanding issues in particle physics, such as the gauge hierarchy problem. SUSY can reveal itself through the production of new heavy particles and could therefore deliver a natural candidate particle to explain the large density of dark matter in the universe. However, it has so far evaded the current searches in both the CMS and ATLAS experiments.
The figure shows a compilation of many of the most recent public results of CMS for integrated luminosities of about 1–2 fb–1. It illustrates the reach of the analyses with respect to pre-LHC experiments in the plane of the universal scalar and gaugino masses (m0 and m1/2, respectively) at the grand unified theory scale of the constrained minimal supersymmetric extension of the Standard Model (CMSSM).
A large increase in sensitivity was clearly obtained at the LHC with the data analysed, obtained in 2010 and until August 2011, but this parameter space is just one reference point among possible SUSY scenarios. Additional data will allow the exploration of other scenarios where each of the signatures, from no-leptons to multileptons, may have the most sensitivity. The search channels shown varied from having a few to many jets (αT, Jets+MHT, MT2), and jets plus one lepton (i.e. generally one muon or electron), jets plus two leptons, with either opposite (OS) or the same (SS) charge. All of these channels were also required to have a large missing transverse energy. The latter is a key characteristic of many SUSY searches, reflecting the supposition that the lightest SUSY particle is expected to be neutral, stable and weakly interacting – thereby escaping detection.
CMS recently released the results of SUSY searches for candidates containing at least three leptons. For these search channels, the Standard Model background is low, mostly di-boson events; this allows the missing transverse energy requirement to be relaxed considerably and so provide sensitivity to SUSY models with so-called R-parity violation. In these models, SUSY particles decay to Standard Model particles and no dark-matter candidate can escape detection. Moreover, such studies are sensitive to the channel of direct electroweak gaugino production, important in scenarios that conserve R-parity.
CMS analysed a total of 2.1 fb–1 of data. In general no significant excess was observed in this new analysis – so SUSY, if it exits, still manages to hide away. As many as 52 different channels have now been looked into and although a few of them show a slight excess over the background estimated from data, all of them currently have a significance of less than 2σ. CMS will certainly continue to “watch this space”.
At the time of this writing, more than 5 fb–1 of data have been recorded and are now being analysed. It promises to be an interesting winter for SUSY searches.
Searches for dilepton resonances have a history of discoveries, from the J/ψ and Υ to the Z boson. Now new neutral gauge bosons, Z’, which would appear as resonances, are predicted by a number of theories. They are the mediators of new forces that allow the unification of all fundamental forces at some very large energy scale. Dilepton resonances are also predicted as gravitons in models of extra-dimensional gravity.
The analysis by ATLAS used a data sample corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 1.1 fb–1. The sensitivity to new physics extends to 1.8 TeV, similar to that of recent preliminary results from CMS and far beyond the limits achieved at lower-energy accelerators. The observed dilepton mass distributions (for example, the di-electron distribution of figure 2) are in good agreement with the spectrum predicted by the Standard Model including higher-order QCD and electroweak corrections.
The search technique employed by ATLAS involves the comparison of the dilepton mass distribution with the predicted spectrum over the entire high-mass range. The prediction includes a series of hypothetical resonance line-shapes with different masses and couplings. The dominant sources of systematic uncertainty are of a theoretical nature, arising from the calculations of the production rates.
The ATLAS detector will measure the mass of any resonance observed quite accurately. The liquid argon calorimeter provides a linear and stable response for electrons up to the highest energy, and the combination of the inner detector and the muon spectrometer provides muon measurement at the highest momenta. ATLAS will also measure the cross-section, couplings, spin and interference properties of a resonance.
Work is ongoing to increase the lepton acceptance further, and ATLAS will extend the kinematic reach of these exciting measurements with much larger datasets in 2011–2012.
A new component of gravity, the scalar gravitational field, may explain the mechanism that allows the immense explosions of type II supernovae to take place. However, this could happen only through a dynamic process – parametric instability – that dates back to work by Lord Rayleigh in the 1880s.
When the central core of a massive star runs out of nuclear fuel (having been converted mainly into iron), it collapses under its own weight in less than a second into an extremely dense neutron star, releasing an enormous amount of gravitational energy. A supernova results, but only a small fraction of the total energy released appears as electromagnetic radiation (light) of the “new star”. The kinetic energy of the exploding stellar envelope is 10 times greater, but the greatest part of the energy by far is carried away by neutrinos, which can more easily escape the dense material of the core.
Detection of neutrinos from supernova SN1987A did much to verify this picture. During core-collapse, the density at the centre of the star rapidly increases, finally forming dense nuclear matter that is extremely difficult to compress. The collapsing material rebounds from this nuclear matter, resulting in an outgoing pressure wave, which soon becomes a huge shock wave.
Extensive studies have attempted to decide whether this “prompt shock” travels all of the way out and ejects the outer part of the star. Indeed, simulations suggest that it stalls at distances of about 300 km from the centre because of the immense energy required to dissociate iron and other nuclei. However, further simulations have found that the shock could restart if the electrons could absorb about 1% of the energy carried by neutrinos. In the neutrino-plasma coupling model, collective interactions between the neutrinos and the plasma could initiate the required energy transfer. Alternatively, recent research suggests that the solution to re-energizing the shock may lie in a fundamental field that takes the simple form of a scalar (like the Higgs field).
Gravity containing a scalar field (originally proposed by Carl Brans and Robert Dicke in the 1960s as an additional component of the gravitational field) has been considered as a promising extension to Einstein’s general relativity in connection with quantum gravity and grand unification. The theory of Brans and Dicke was based on a relatively simple linear coupling to the scalar gravitational field. A few years ago, this linear coupling was shown to be negligible, using radio signals transmitted from the Cassini spacecraft when it was near Saturn.
Now, researchers in the UK and Portugal have analysed the nonlinear coupling to a scalar gravitational field. They find that under extreme conditions with strong time-varying gravity such as may be found in the interior of a newly born neutron star, the scalar gravitational field may be stimulated via parametric instability. The resulting emission of scalar gravitational waves from the neutron core of a collapsing heavy star may be sufficient to re-energize the stalled shock, thus providing a 19th-century solution to a 20th-century problem.
The 13th international conference on Strangeness in Quark Matter (SQM 2011) took place in Krakow on 18–24 September. Organized by the Polish Academy of Arts and Sciences (Polska Akademia Umiejętności, PAU), it attracted more than 160 participants from 20 countries. The emphasis was on new data on the production of strangeness and heavy flavours in heavy-ion and hadronic collisions, in particular the new results from the LHC at CERN and the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) at Brookhaven. With the new high-quality data on identified particles, SQM 2011 in a sense supplemented the Quark Matter conference that was held in Annecy in May.
Summary talks during the first two morning sessions introduced the experimental highlights for the main heavy-ion experiments currently in operation. They included data at energies ranging from the Heavy Ion Synchrotron (SIS) at GSI (the HADES and FOPI experiments), through the Super Proton Synchrotron at CERN (NA49 and NA61) and RHIC (PHENIX and STAR), up to the LHC (ALICE, ATLAS and CMS), as well as prospects for new or future facilities, such as the Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research (FAIR) and the Nuclotron-based Ion Collider Facility (NICA).
In this report we can cover only a small selection of the impressive wealth of new results and information presented at the conference. The following highlights illustrate some of the most recent measurements in nucleus–nucleus collisions at the LHC and in the Beam Energy Scan programme at RHIC. All of them focus on results obtained in the sectors of strange and heavy quarks, which traditionally form the major part of the discussions at SQM conferences.
Experimental results
Maria Nicassio of the University and INFN Bari for the ALICE collaboration presented preliminary results on the production of the charged multi-strange hadrons Ξ–and Ω– and their antiparticles, from peripheral to the most central lead–lead collisions at the current maximum centre-of-mass energy of 2.76 TeV per equivalent nucleon–nucleon (SUSY: the search continues). The enhancement of these particle yields normalized to the number of nucleons participating in the collision and compared with proton–proton (pp) production was shown for the first time (figure 1). As already found in heavy-ion collisions at the SPS and RHIC, the yields at the LHC cannot be achieved in a hadronic phase only, but require a fast equilibration and a large correlation volume. For these reasons, the enhanced production of multi-strange baryons is regarded as one of the signals for the phase transition from ordinary hadronic matter to the quark–gluon plasma (QGP). It was also stressed that, although the absolute production of hyperons increases with energy from RHIC to the LHC, both in heavy-ion and in pp collisions, the relative enhancement decreases as a result of a significant increase in pp yields at the LHC.
Using the Beam Energy Scan at RHIC, the STAR collaboration has progressed significantly with tackling the evolution of the collective effects observed in heavy-ion (Au–Au) collisions between √sNN=7.7 GeV and 62.4 GeV, as Shusu Shi of Central China Normal University showed. While studying the excitation function of the second harmonic v2 in the azimuthal distribution of particle (π, K, p and Λ) production, the collaboration identified a significant difference in the behaviour of particles and antiparticles for 0–80% central Au–Au reactions (figure 2). The increasing deviation in v2 between particles and antiparticles, observed with decreasing √sNN, is more pronounced for baryons, such as protons and Λs, than for mesons (charged π and K). However, it must be noted that above 39 GeV, the difference in v2 between particles and antiparticles remains almost constant to higher energies at about 5–10%. The large difference between particle and antiparticle v2 at lower energies could thus be related to an increased amount of transported quarks to mid-rapidity or it could indicate that hadronic interactions become dominant below 11.5 GeV. In the latter case, the difference in v2 could be attributed to different interaction cross-sections of particles and antiparticles in hadronic matter of high baryon density.
The ALICE collaboration also presented preliminary results on the azimuthal anisotropy (v2) of charm production in non-central lead–lead collisions at the LHC, in a talk by Chiara Bianchin of the University and INFN Padova. Such a measurement was highly anticipated, after the observation of a large suppression of charmed-meson yields in nucleus–nucleus collisions, which implies strong quenching of charm quarks in dense QGP. The study of charm anisotropy would provide insight on the degree of thermalization of the quenched charm quarks within QGP. Figure 3 shows the v2 parameter of D0 mesons, reconstructed in the K–π+ channel, as a function of transverse momentum (in red), compared with that of charged hadrons (in black). This measurement, though statistically limited, hints at a non-zero charm v2 at low momentum and bodes well for the continuation of the study with the higher-luminosity lead run in 2011.
Theoretical discussions
The conference witnessed a lively debate on theoretical issues. In the theoretical summary talk, Giorgio Torrieri of the Goethe University, Frankfurt, pointed to various differences in the interpretation of heavy-ion data (e.g. equilibrated vs non-equilibrated hadron gas; statistical vs non-statistical production in small systems). Probably everyone connected with the SQM conferences is enthusiastic about the fact that statistical models do an excellent job in describing hadron production in heavy-ion and hadronic collisions, with the key role being played by the fast strange-quark thermalization. Perhaps, this attitude just defines the SQM community. On the other hand, there exist differences in the approaches and interpretations that should be resolved if the community is to gain a better understanding of hadron production processes. The relatively low proton-to-pion production ratio measured recently by ALICE, presented by Alexander Kalweit of the Technische Universität Darmstadt, will trigger such attempts.
The analysis of the data has led to a physical picture that may be regarded as a kind of standard model of relativistic heavy-ion collisions. This model is based on the application of relativistic hydrodynamics combined with the modelling of the initial state on one side, supplemented by the kinetic simulations of freeze-out on the other side. From the theoretical point of view, it is not completely clear how strange particles may be accommodated into this picture, both at RHIC and at the LHC. The results obtained from 2+1 dissipative hydrodynamics, presented by Piotr Bozek of the Institute of Nuclear Physics, Krakow, indicate that the multi-strange particle spectra measured at the LHC cannot be simply reproduced in hydrodynamic calculations that are constructed to describe ordinary hadrons, such as pions, kaons and protons. The new LHC measurement of the elliptic flow of D0 mesons shown in figure 3 will be another important input for hydrodynamic and energy-loss models. As Christoph Blume of the University of Heidelberg indicated, the general concept that strange particles are emitted much earlier than other more abundant hadrons may be challenged in attempts to achieve a uniform description of several observables simultaneously.
Another theoretical activity presented at SQM 2011 was triggered by low-energy experiments aimed at finding the critical point of QCD (RHIC Beam Energy Scan, NA61, FAIR, NICA). This critical point marks the end of the alleged first-order phase transition in the QCD phase diagram. Its position is suggested by the effective models of QCD and lattice QCD simulations. These two approaches suffer from fundamental problems but, nevertheless, deliver useful physical insights. For example, as Christian Schmidt of the Frankfurt Institute for Advanced Studies showed, the lattice QCD calculations suggest that the curvature of the chiral phase-transition line is smaller than that of the freeze-out curve. Moreover, the lattice results are in agreement with the STAR data on net-proton fluctuations. As Krzysztof Redlich of the University of Wroclaw pointed out, theoretical probability distributions of conserved charges may be compared directly with the distributions measured by STAR to probe the critical behaviour.
The last day of the meeting was the occasion for more experimental highlights, presented in the summary talk by Karel Safarik of CERN. The conference ended with a presentation by Orlando Villalobos-Baillie of the next SQM meeting, which will be held in Birmingham, UK, in 2013.
Andrzej Bialas, the founder and the leader of the high-energy physics theoretical group in Krakow, who is currently the president of PAU, was the honorary chair of the conference. The organization chairs were Wojtek Broniowski and Wojtek Florkowski of Jan Kochanowski University, Kielce, and the Institute of Nuclear Physics, Krakow.
Since the first LHC collisions about two years ago, the ATLAS experiment has performed superbly – collecting quality data with high efficiency, processing the data in a timely way and preparing and publishing many new physics results. During this time the LHC has delivered more than 5 fb–1 of proton–proton collision data at √s=7 TeV. Using a good fraction of these data, the collaboration has carried out Higgs-boson searches, as well as searches beyond the Standard Model. While no new physics has been observed, ATLAS is setting stringent limits on the production cross-sections of new particles, including – but not limited to – the Higgs boson predicted by the Standard Model. Accurate measurements of Standard Model physics quantities have been performed covering many orders of magnitude in cross-section, with a precision often comparable to or exceeding that of the predictions.
These accomplishments have not been as easy as they may appear. Built on the tremendous success of the LHC, they are also the product of the strength and hard work of the 3000-member ATLAS collaboration. This article recounts the story of the first two years of the ATLAS physics programme, with an eye to some of the special occurrences and accomplishments along the way. However, it represents only the tip of the iceberg as far as the reach of the LHC physics programme is concerned. So far, ATLAS has collected just a small percentage of the total luminosity expected over the lifetime of the LHC.
Major progress
Before any physics analysis can be carried out, many members of the ATLAS collaboration work tirelessly to ready and tune the detectors, data acquisition, and trigger, to collect and reconstruct the data, and to check the quality of the data. Other members work to understand and characterize the various reconstructed objects seen in the detector. These are electrons, muons, τ leptons, photons, jets, missing transverse energy and identified heavy flavour. In two years ATLAS has gone from beginning to understand charged particles in the inner detector to using complex neural networks for flavour tagging. Algorithms have also progressed, for example from simple calorimeter-based definitions of missing transverse energy to more sophisticated definitions correcting for the calibrations and energies of the various objects.
The general complexity of the ATLAS results has followed a similar progression, from counting events for processes with large cross-sections, through using advanced analysis techniques to extract small signals from large backgrounds. Some analyses used complex unfolding techniques to compare measurements in the best way to parton-level predictions, and some have used modern statistical tools that allow the combination of many different channels into a single physics interpretation.
Figure 1 summarizes the production cross-sections for the main Standard Model processes and shows the luminosity used to measure these processes. The W and Z inclusive cross-sections and the Wγ and Zγ cross-sections were measured with the approximately 35 pb–1 from 2010. The tt cross-section is based on a statistical combination of measurements using dilepton final states with 0.70 fb–1 of data and single-lepton final states with 35 pb–1. The other measurements were made with the 2011 dataset. After only two years of running ATLAS can now measure processes with cross-section times branching ratio down to around 10 pb.
One of the by-products of the excellent LHC performance is another increase in complexity: the presence of multiple interactions within the same bunch crossing (pile-up). The 40 pb–1 of data recorded in 2010 had an average of 3 interactions per bunch crossing (<μ>), allowing good quality measurements in a relatively clean environment. The LHC run in 2011 was characterized by a rapid increase in instantaneous luminosity from the beginning of the machine operations in March, reaching <μ> of 10 in August. Figure 2 shows the complexity of an event with a Z→μμ candidate produced in a bunch crossing with 11 reconstructed proton–proton interaction vertices. The time for the integrated luminosity to double at the beginning of the run was less than one week. Since the end of May this year, the machine has regularly delivered more luminosity in one day than the total delivered in 2010.
First results
In the beginning, analyses focused mostly on understanding and measuring properties using single detectors. The first ATLAS publication on collisions reported the charged-particle multiplicities and distributions as a function of the transverse momentum pT and pseudo-rapidity η, analysing the data taken in December 2009 (√s=0.9 TeV). This allowed validation of the charged-particle reconstruction, providing important feedback on the modelling of the alignment of the detector as well as on the distribution of the material. These results, and those from a more detailed later study, were also used to tune the parameters of the Monte Carlo modelling of non-perturbative processes, which is now used to model the effect of the multiple interactions for the latest data.
Using only 17 nb–1 of recorded data, the production cross-sections of inclusive jets and dijets have been measured over a range of jet transverse-momenta, up to 0.6 TeV. Figure 3 shows the event with the highest central dijet-mass recorded by ATLAS in 2010. These measurements allowed the first accurate tests of QCD at the LHC. The differential cross-sections showed a remarkably good agreement with next-to-leading (NLO) perturbative QCD (pQCD) calculations, corrected for non-perturbative effects, in this unexplored kinematic regime. Given the good agreement of data and the Standard Model predictions, the study of dijet final states was used to set limits on the mass of new physics objects such as excited quarks Q*: excluding 0.30<mQ* <1.26 TeV at 95% confidence level (CL).
The first few hundred inverse nanobarns of data allowed early searches for new physics, looking for quark-contact interactions in dijet final-state events by studying the χ variable associated with a jet pair, where χ=exp|y*| and y* is the scattering rapidity evaluated in the centre-of-mass frame. The data were fully consistent with Standard Model expectations and allowed quark-contact interactions to be excluded at 95% CL with a compositeness scale Λ=3.4 TeV. Using about 100 times more data than the first jet results, ATLAS studied more complex multi-jet production, with up to six jets per event in the kinematic region of pTjet>60 GeV.
Accurate measurements of Standard Model quantities have been performed covering many orders of magnitude in cross-section
ATLAS was soon able to combine measurements from many detector components and reconstruct more of the Standard Model particles. A study of Standard Model production of gauge bosons (W± and Z0/γ*) was performed with the first 330 nb–1 of data, in the lν and ll final states (l=e or μ). Both the measurements of the inclusive production cross-section times branching fraction σW,Z ×BR(W,Z→ lν, ll) and the ratio of the two agree well with next-to-NLO calculations (NNLO) within experimental and theoretical uncertainties.
By combining measurements from the calorimeters and the central inner tracker, ATLAS was able to analyse the production of inclusive high-pT photons and perform extensive QCD studies. For this, additional complexity resides in the need to model and understand significant background contributions. These were estimated for this analysis from data, based on the observed distribution of the transverse isolation energy around the photon candidate. A comparison of results to predictions from NLO pQCD calculations again showed remarkable agreement.
An initial measurement of the production cross-section for top-quark pairs was already possible with just a small fraction of the 2010 data. Combining information from almost all detector systems, events were selected with either a single lepton produced together with at least four high-pT jets plus large transverse missing energy, or two leptons in association with at least two high-pT jets and large transverse missing energy. In this analysis ATLAS used b-jet identification algorithms for the first time – crucial for the rejection of the large backgrounds that do not contain b-quarks. A total of 37 single-lepton and 9 dilepton events were selected, in good agreement with Standard Model predictions.
The use of all of the 2010 data allowed ATLAS to study more complex quantities and distributions. For example, the W and Z differential cross-sections were measured as functions of the boson transverse-momentum, allowing more extensive tests of pQCD. Using the ratio of the difference between the number of the positive and the negative Ws to their sum, ATLAS measured the W charge-asymmetry as a function of the boson pseudo-rapidity. These results provided the first input from ATLAS on the fractions of u and d quark momentum of the proton.
At this stage, the analysis of W→τν and Z→ττ represented an important step in commissioning the selection of hadronic τ final states that are crucial in searches for new physics as well as for the Higgs boson. More accurate studies of top physics were also performed, from the inclusive cross-section for tt pairs to a preliminary measurement of the top quark’s mass.
New experiences
The full 2010 dataset also offered the first concrete possibility to look for physics signals beyond the Standard Model over a wide spectrum of final states. Events with high-pT jets or leptons and with large missing transverse momentum were studied extensively to search for supersymmetric (SUSY) particles. Here, more complex variables were used, such as the “effective mass” (the sum of the transverse momentum of selected jets, leptons and missing transverse energy), which is sensitive to the production of new particles. No significant excess of events was found in the data and limits were set on the mass of squarks and gluinos, m&qtilde; and m>ilde;, assuming simplified SUSY models. If m&qtilde; = m>ilde; and the mass of the lightest stable SUSY particle is mχ01=0, then the limit is about 850 GeV at 95% CL. Limits have been placed assuming other SUSY interpretations, such as minimal supergravity grand unification (MSUGRA) and the constrained minimal supersymmetric extension of the Standard Model (CMSSM).
The 2010 run ended with a short period in November dedicated to lead-ion collisions with a centre-of-mass energy per nucleon √sNN = 2.76 TeV. This was certainly one of the most amazing experiences for ATLAS during the first two years of collisions at the LHC. As the online event display in the ATLAS control room brought up the first event images, the calorimeter plot showed many events where a narrow cluster of calorimeter cells with high-energy deposits (a jet) were poorly – or not at all – balanced in the transverse plane by equivalent activity in the back-to-back region (figure 4). The gut feeling was clear: this was the first direct observation of jet-quenching in heavy-ion collisions. A detailed analysis of the early lead-collision data studied the dijet asymmetry – defined as Aj = (ETj1–ETj2)/(ETj1+ETj2), where ETji is the transverse jet energy calibrated at the hadronic scale – as a function of the event “centrality”. This showed that the transverse energies of dijets in opposite hemispheres become systematically more unbalanced with increasing event “centrality”, leading to a large number of events that contain highly asymmetric dijets. Such an effect was not observed in proton–proton collisions, pointing to an interpretation in terms of strong jet-energy loss in a hot, dense medium.
The early part of data-taking in 2011 was an extremely intense period. Already in June, ATLAS presented the first preliminary results on eight analyses using about 300 pb–1 of data, almost 10 times the integrated luminosity of 2010. This allowed more stringent limits to be placed on SUSY particles, heavy bosons W’ and Z’, new particles decaying to tt pairs, and on the production cross-section of a Standard Model Higgs boson decaying to photon-pair final states. It also allowed the first limits on particles with masses above 1 TeV.
Using a similar dataset ATLAS reported preliminary results on the production of single top at the LHC
Using a similar dataset ATLAS reported preliminary results on the production of single top at the LHC, looking in particular to the t-channel process, where a b-quark from the sea scatters with a valence quark. This process is particularly important, as any deviation from QCD predictions may indicate the presence of new physics beyond the Standard Model. The analysis is extremely difficult as the signal is hidden under a large non-reducible background from W+jets. It requires complex methods that make use of the full kinematic information of the events, looking simultaneously at many different distributions.
Extending the search with 1 fb–1
While ATLAS was carrying out these analyses, the LHC completed delivery of the first inverse femtobarn, opening up a number of new physics channels. The collaboration quickly released results on a total of 35 physics analyses with these data, most of them having to deal with the increased level of pile-up.
Preliminary WW, WZ and ZZ diboson production cross-section measurements show an overall precision of about 15% (WW and WZ) or 30% (ZZ). These measurements, all consistent with the Standard Model predictions, represent an important foundation for searches for the Standard Model Higgs boson. Triple-gauge couplings have been studied and found to be in agreement with the Standard Model, allowing limits to be placed on the size of anomalous couplings of this kind.
The 2011 data allowed more sensitive searches for SUSY particles, using similar or more complex distributions than in 2010. Once more, the results are in good agreement with the Standard Model expectations and have again been interpreted in the MSUGRA/CMSSM models as well as in simplified models. These studies exclude squarks and gluinos in simplified models with masses less than about 1.08 TeV at 95% CL.
ATLAS has also performed searches for dijet, lepton–neutrino and lepton–lepton resonances. Figure 5 shows the invariant mass distribution for an electron and missing transverse-energy. These searches have placed limits on new heavy-quark masses, mQ* >1.92 TeV, and on the mass of W’ and Z’ predicted by a number of different models, mW’ > 2.15 TeV and mZ’ > 1.83 TeV, all at the 95% CL.
The 2011 data began to open up the search for the Standard Model Higgs boson. To cover the entire mass range, from about 110 GeV (the limit from the Large Electron Positron collider is 114.4 GeV at 95% CL) to the highest possible values (around 600 GeV), this exploration was conducted in several final states: H→ γγ; ττ; WW(*)→lνlν, lνqq; ZZ(*)→llll, llνν, llqq as well as H→bb produced in association with a W or Z.
In the analysis dedicated to the search for H→γγ processes, events with pairs of high-pT photons were selected and the photons combined to reconstruct the invariant mass. The accurate measurement of the direction of flight of the photons is crucial for obtaining high mass-resolution and hence a strong rejection of background processes, in particular, QCD diphoton production. This is possible in ATLAS thanks to the longitudinal segmentation of the electromagnetic calorimeter, which in addition allows a strong rejection of fake photons produced by QCD jets. This channel alone allowed exclusion at the level of about three times the cross-section predicted by the Standard Model.
The analysis dedicated to the search for H→WW*→ lνlν was based on the selection of high-pT lepton pairs, electrons and muons, produced in association with large transverse missing energy. Two independent final-state classes were considered, depending on whether 0 or 1 high-pT jets were reconstructed in the same event. The analysis revealed no excess events, excluding the production of a Standard Model Higgs boson with mass in the interval 154<mH<186 GeV at 95% CL and thereby enlarging the mass region already excluded by the Tevatron.
The golden channel H→ZZ(*)→4l is based on a conceptually simple analysis: the selection of events with isolated dimuon or di-electron pairs, associated to the same hard-scattering proton–proton vertex. ATLAS found the rate of 4-lepton events to be fully consistent with the expectations from background; the analysis excludes a Higgs boson produced with a cross-section close to that predicted by the Standard Model throughout nearly the entire mass interval from 200 to 400 GeV. No evidence for an excess of events has been found in all other analysed channels, allowing 95% CL exclusion limits to be placed for each of them.
Last, ATLAS used complex statistical methods to combine the information from all of these Higgs decay channels into a single limit. While the Standard Model does not predict the mass of the Higgs boson, it does predict the production cross-section and branching ratios once the mass is known. Figure 6 shows, as a function of the Higgs mass, the Higgs boson production cross-section excluded at 95% CL by ATLAS, in terms of the Standard Model cross-section. If the solid black line (the observed limit) dips below 1, then the data exclude the production of the Standard Model Higgs at 95% CL at that mass. If the solid black line is above 1, the production of a Standard Model Higgs cannot be excluded at that mass. As figure 6 shows, the data exclude the Standard Model Higgs boson in the mass range 146<mH<466 GeV at 95% CL, with the exception of the mass intervals 232<mH <256 GeV and 282<mH <296 GeV.
This article has been able to present only a few of the ATLAS results using up to the first inverse femtobarn of data. In 2011 the experiment collected more than 5 fb–1, so the collaboration is working hard on the analysis of the new data in time for presentation of new results at the “winter” conferences early in 2012 . The first results presented here represent only a few per cent of the total data ultimately expected from the LHC. We look forward to many more exciting and impressive years.
The roots of the first conference on Advances in Radioactive Isotope Science, ARIS 2011, go back to CERN in 1964, when the then director-general Victor Weisskopf called for proposals for on-line experiments to study radioactive nuclei at the 600 MeV synchrocyclotron. Why this should be done – and how – became the subject of a conference held in Lysekil, Sweden, in 1966 and a year later experiments began at ISOLDE, CERN’s Isotope Separator On Line. Following this successful start, in 1970 CERN organized a first meeting on nuclei far from stability in Leysin, Switzerland.
Since then there have been regular conferences within the field, with more specialized meetings arising hand in hand with increasingly sophisticated technical developments (see box). Three years ago the community felt that the time was ripe to streamline the conferences by merging all of the physics into a single meeting held every three years. The result was that at the end of May this year some 300 physicists met in the beautiful medieval town of Leuven in Belgium to attend ARIS 2011. The success of the meeting, with its excellent scientific programme, indicates that this was the perfect decision.
Over the past two decades the experimental possibilities for studying exotic nuclear systems have increased dramatically thanks to impressive technical developments for the production of rare nuclear species, both at rest and as energetic beams. New sophisticated detection methods and data-acquisition techniques with on- and off-line analysis methods have also been developed. The two basic techniques now used at laboratories worldwide are the isotope separator on-line (ISOL) and in-flight production methods, with several variations.
The conference heard the latest news about plans to make major improvements to existing facilities or to build new facilities, offering new research opportunities. The review of the first results from the new major in-flight facility, the Radioactive Isotope Beam Factory at the RIKEN research institute in Japan, was particularly exciting. The production of 45 new neutron-rich isotopes together with results from the Zero-Degree Spectrometer and the radioactive-ion beam separator, BigRIPS, gave a glimpse of the facility’s quality. Future installations, such as the Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research (FAIR) at GSI, SPIRAL2 at the GANIL laboratory, the High Intensity and Energy ISOLDE at CERN, the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams at Michigan State University (MSU) and the Advanced Rare Isotope Laboratory at TRIUMF were also discussed, together with the advanced plans to build EURISOL, a major new European facility complementary to FAIR.
The nuclear mass is arguably the most basic information to be gained for an isotope. Its measurement has involved various techniques, but a paradigm shift came with the development of mass spectrometers based on Penning traps and such devices are now coupled to the majority of radioactive-beam facilities. This has led to mass-determinations of unprecedented precision for isotopes in all regions of the nuclear chart, making it possible in effect to walk round the mass “landscape” and scrutinize its details (figure 3).
Recent results from the ISOLTRAP mass spectrometer at CERN, which has been in operation for more than 20 years, have a precision in the order of 10–8 for the masses of isotopes with half-lives down to milliseconds. The first determination of masses of neutron-rich francium isotopes, where the mass of 228Fr (T1/2 = 39 s) is a notable example, were presented at ARIS 2011. The JYFLTRAP group, using the IGISOL facility at the physics department of the University of Jyväskylä (JYFL), presented masses for about 40 neutron-rich isotopes in the medium-mass region. The SHIPTRAP spectrometer at GSI has made measurements of masses towards the region of super-heavy elements; 256Lr, produced at a rate of only two atoms a minute, is the heaviest element studied so far. The TRISTAN spectrometer at TRIUMF has boosted precision by “breeding” isotopes to higher charge-states – for example, in a new measurement of the mass of the super-allowed β-emitter 74Rb, which is relevant to the unitarity of the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix. Results from isochronous mass-spectroscopy with the CSRe storage ring at the National Laboratory of Heavy Ion Research in Lanzhou were also presented. Ion-traps are now routinely used as a key instrument for cooling and bunching the radioactive beams. This gives an improvement of several orders of magnitude in the peak-to-background ratio in laser spectroscopy experiments, or can be used prior to post-acceleration.
The determination of nuclear matter and charge radii has been important to the progress of radioactive-beam physics. The observation of shape co-existence in mercury isotopes at ISOLDE was the starting point for impressive developments, with lasers playing the key role. The most recent results from the same area of the nuclear chart are measurements using the Resonance Ionization Laser Ion Source at ISOLDE of isotope shifts and charge radii for the isotope chain 191–218Po. Another demonstration of the state of the art was shown in the determination of the charge radius of 12Be using collinear laser spectroscopy based on a frequency comb together with a photon-ion coincidence technique. Electron scattering from radioactive beams will be the next step for investigating nuclear shapes; the ELISe project at GSI and SCRIT at RIKEN are examples of such plans.
The determination of matter radii by transmission techniques, pioneered at Berkeley in the mid-1980s, led to the discovery of halo states in nuclei. These are well known today but the main data are limited to the lightest region of the nuclear chart. A step towards heavier cases was presented at ARIS in new data from RIKEN, where results from RIPS and BigRIPS indicate a halo state for 22C and 31Ne and maybe also for 37Mg.
The use of laser spectroscopy in measuring charge radii, nuclear spins, magnetic moments and electric quadrupole moments has been extremely successful over the years. New results from the IGISOL facility – mapping the sudden onset of deformation at N = 60 – and from the ISOLDE cooler/buncher ISCOOL – for copper and gallium isotopes – were highlighted at the conference. The two-neutron halo nucleus 11Li continues to attract interest both theoretically and experimentally, where a better determination of the ratio of the electric quadrupole moments between mass 11 and 9 was needed. Now a measurement at TRIUMF based on a β-detected nuclear-quadrupole resonance technique has yielded a value of Q(11Li)/Q(9Li) = 1.077(1). Here, the cross-fertilization between beam and detector developments has led to laser-resonant ionization becoming an essential ingredient in the production cycle of pure radioactive, sometimes isomeric, beams.
Nuclear-structure studies of exotic nuclei were the topic of many contributions at ARIS. There is progress on the theoretical side with large-scale shell model calculations in the vicinity of 78Ni leading to a unified description of neutron-rich nuclei between N = 40 and N = 50. The evolution of collectivity for the N = 40 isotopes has provided many interesting experimental results. From the strongly deformed N = Z nucleus 80Zr, collectivity is rapidly decreasing to 68Ni with a high-lying 2+ state at 2.03 MeV, suggesting a doubly magic character. Going to 64Cr, there is a new deformed region illustrated by a 2+ state at 470 keV, and research at the National Superconducting Cyclotron Laboratory at MSU has found an enhanced collectivity for 78Sr, with a quadrupole deformation parameter of β2=0.44.
Many of the talks at ARIS addressed the “island of inversion”. A recent result from REX-ISOLDE identifies an excited 0+ state in 32Mg, illustrating shape coexistence at the borders of the island. Many new results – a rotational band in 38Mg observed by BigRIPS, isotope shifts for 21–32Mg measured at ISOLDE, β-decay for chromium isotopes from Berkeley and shape-coexistence in 34Si and 44S – add to the understanding of this interesting region of the nuclear chart. A new island of inversion, indicated by data for 80–84Ga from the ALTO facility in Orsay, was also discussed.
Continuing with nuclear structure, data from GANIL and its MUST 2 array on d(68Ni, p)69Ni give access to the d5/2 orbital, which is crucial for understanding shell structure and deformation in this mass region. The reaction d(34Si, p)35Si shows a density dependence of the spin-orbit splitting leading to a depletion of the nuclear matter density and resulting in a “bubble nucleus” – a topic also discussed in a theory talk.
The doubly magic nucleus 24O has attracted interest for a decade, from experimental and theoretical viewpoints. At ARIS, the coupled-cluster approach was presented as an ideal compromise between computational costs and numerical accuracy in theoretical models, while the absence of bound oxygen isotopes up to the classically expected doubly magic nucleus 28O presents a theoretical challenge.
Experimentally, there is an impressive series of data – over a wide range of elements – from the MINIBALL array at ISOLDE. One of the highlights here was the observation of shape coexistence in the lead region. A theory talk pointed out that the nuclear energy-density functional approach, both for mean-field and beyond-mean-field applications, is an efficient tool for calculations on medium-mass and heavy nuclei.
Early experiments with radioactive beams revealed exotic decay-modes such as β-delayed particle emission. Today these processes are well understood and used as workhorses to learn about the structure of exotic nuclei. The study of β-delayed three-proton emission from 43Cr and two-proton radioactivity from 48Ni using an Optical Time Projection Chamber at MSU was also presented at ARIS. Here it is clear that in future the study of the most exotic decay modes will use active targets, such as in the Maya detector developed at GANIL and the ACTAR-TPC project being planned by GANIL together with MSU. An interesting new result concerns the observation of β-delayed fission-precursors in the Hg-Tl region, where an unexpected asymmetric fragment-distribution has been observed for the β-delayed fission of 180Tl.
Unbound nuclei or resonance states are sometimes debated as “ghosts” without any physics significance. However, developments over the past 5–10 years have provided a huge amount of data, so that most of the previously empty spots on the nuclear chart for the light elements are now filled. The production of 10He and 12,13Li from proton-knockout reactions from 11Li and 14Be, respectively, is a particularly spectacular case. The knockout of a strongly bound proton from the almost unbound nucleus 14Be results in a 11Li nucleus that together with two neutrons shows features that can only be attributed to an unbound 13Li nucleus. Many of the resonance states might be populated in transfer reactions in inverse kinematics, in which the exotic nuclei are used as an energetic beam directed towards a target that was earlier used as the beam. The HELIOS spectrometer, which will use neutron-rich beams from the CARIBU injector at the Argonne Tandem Linear Accelerator System, is a model for what might develop at many facilities in the future.
The super-heavy-element community was represented in several talks at ARIS. Having produced all elements up to Z = 118, the next step is to tackle the Z = 120 barrier, an exciting goal that could become a reality with reactions such as 54Cr+248Cm. Nuclear spectroscopy is also climbing towards ever higher mass numbers and elements, as demonstrated by data from JYFL for 254No. One exciting talk concerned the chemical identification of isotopes of element 114 (287,288Uuq), which is found to belong to group 14 (in modern notation) in the periodic table – the group that contains lead, tin, germanium, silicon and carbon.
The acquisition of data pertinent to nuclear astrophysics has grown tremendously thanks to the access to nuclei in relevant regions of the nuclear chart. Results include the study at JYFL and at the Nuclear-physics Accelerator Institute (KVI), Groningen, of β-decay of 8B for the solar-neutrino problem and the work at ISOLDE, JYFL and KVI on β-decays of 12N and 12B, which are important for the production of 12C in astrophysical environments. Data from ISOLDE and JYFL on the neutron-deficient nuclei 31Ar and 23Al, relevant for explosive hydrogen burning, were also discussed, as were results from MSU relating to the hot carbon–nitrogen–oxygen cycle and the αp-, rp- and r-processes in nucleosynthesis. GANIL has results on the reaction d(60Fe,p)61Fe, which is relevant for type II supernovae, while the Radioactive Ion Beam Facility in Brazil in São Paulo has data on the p(8Li,α)5He reaction. Calculations for proton scattering on 7Be in a many-body approach, combining the resonating-group method with the ab initio no-core shell model, were also described at the conference.
Exotic nuclei can also provide information about fundamental symmetries and interactions. The painstaking collection of data over decades has provided an extremely sensitive test of the unitarity of the top row of the CKM matrix. Today there are precise data for 13 super-allowed β-emitters, which give a value of 0.99990(60) for this quantity. In this context, there are plans for measurements with the Magneto Optical Trap at Argonne of β-neutrino correlations for 6He and the electric dipole moment for 225Ra. The high-precision set-ups – WITCH at CERN, LPC Trap at GANIL and WIRED at the Weizmann Institute – were also discussed at the conference. The claim is that this kind of experiment – the high-precision frontier – will to some extent complement the high-energy frontier in understanding the deepest secrets of nature.
Finally, a review of the different techniques using radioactive isotopes in solid-state physics presented the current state of the art, together with some recent results. This work was pioneered at CERN and has over the years become an important ingredient at many facilities.
In summary, ARIS 2011 turned out to be a successful merger of the former ENAM and RNB conferences (see box). The talks, supported by an excellent poster show, covered the field perfectly. The talks are available on the conference website and the organizers had the excellent idea of putting the posters there too – this is “a first”, to be followed in future.
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional
Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
