Comsol -leaderboard other pages

Topics

EPS-HEP 2011: the harvest begins

CCnew1_06_11

Impressive results, and so much more to come: this is the general feeling that more than 800 participants took home from the International Europhysics Conference on High-Energy Physics, EPS-HEP 2011, which was held in Grenoble on 21–27 July. After only a year of data-taking, the spectacular performance of the LHC and the amazingly fast data analysis by the experiments have raised current knowledge by a huge notch in searches for new physics.

Those who had hoped that the LHC would reveal supersymmetry early on may have been slightly disappointed, although each extended limit contributes to the correct picture and new physics is guaranteed, as many speakers reminded the audience. CERN’s director-general, Rolf Heuer reinforced this point, stating that for the Higgs boson in particular, either finding it or excluding it will be a great discovery.

On the search for the Higgs boson, both the CMS and ATLAS experiments at the LHC have observed small excesses of events in the WW and ZZ channels. Each one is statistically weak but taken together, they become interesting, as each team independently sees a small excess in the low range for the Higgs mass. While this is exactly how a Standard Model Higgs would manifest itself, it is still far too early to tell (The LHC homes in on the Higgs).

Another big topic of conversation was the report by the CDF collaboration at Fermilab of the first measurement of the rare decay Bs→μμ, appearing possibly stronger than predicted. On the other hand, the CMS and LHCb collaborations at the LHC showed preliminary results, which when combined provide a limit in contradiction with the CDF result (CMS and LHCb pull together in search for rare decay). More data will soon clarify what is happening here.

The session on QCD showed great progress in the field, with updates on parton-distribution functions from the experiments at HERA, DESY, as well as several results from the LHC experiments. These measurements are now challenging the precision of theoretical predictions, and will contribute towards refining the Monte Carlo simulations further. The experiments at Fermilab’s Tevatron and at the B-factories also presented improved and impressive limits in all directions in flavour physics, contributing to a clearer theoretical picture.

In neutrino physics, new results came from the T2K and MINOS experiments, giving the first indications of a sizeable mixing angle between the first and third neutrino generations (MINOS and T2K glimpse electron neutrinos). It was particularly moving to see how Japanese colleagues are recovering after the devastating earthquake and tsunami. Atsuko Suzuki, head of the KEK laboratory, thanked the particle-physics community for its extended support.

An important highlight of the conference was the award of the European Physical Society (EPS) High Energy and Particle Physics Prize to Sheldon Lee Glashow, John Iliopoulos and Luciano Maiani. They received this for their crucial contribution to the theory of flavour, currently embedded in the Standard Model of strong and electroweak interactions, which is still of utmost importance today.

With the first results from significant amounts of data at the LHC, the conference attracted a great deal of interest from the world’s press. A press conference was held on 25 July to announce the EPS 2011 high-energy physics prizes, with contributions on the latest results from the LHC, the European strategy for particle physics, and the latest advances in astroparticle physics in Europe.

• A more detailed report will appear in the October issue of the CERN Courier.

MINOS and T2K glimpse electron-neutrinos

The T2K and MINOS experiments, which are both designed to study neutrino oscillations over long baselines, have reported results from their searches for the appearance of electron-neutrinos in beams of muon-neutrinos produced at distant locations. On 15 June the T2K collaboration announced that it had observed an indication that muon-neutrinos are able to transform into electron-neutrinos over the 295 km baseline of their experiment in Japan. Ten days later, the MINOS collaboration announced its latest results on the same effect. Both experiments find a non-zero value for the neutrino mixing angle θ13. This would be zero if electron- and muon-neutrinos could not transform into each other.

Oscillations between the three known flavours of neutrino – electron, muon and tau – are described by a mixing matrix, which can be parameterized in terms of three angles, θ12, θ23, θ13, and a CP-violating phase. Observations of oscillations in solar neutrinos and atmospheric neutrinos have determined θ12 and θ23, respectively, leaving θ13 still unknown. The new results provide the first indications that this angle is not zero, via values of sin213.

The collaboration found 88 neutrino events registered in the Super-Kamiokande detector

T2K (Tokai to Kamioka) uses the Super-Kamiokande detector in Kamioka to detect neutrinos produced at the Japan Proton Accelerator Research Complex (J-PARC) situated 295 km away. The new results are from an analysis based on all of the data collected between January 2010 – when the experiment began full operation – and 11 March 2011, when it was interrupted by the enormous earthquake in East Japan. This corresponds to a total of 1.43 × 1020 protons on the neutrino-production target. The collaboration found 88 neutrino events registered in the Super-Kamiokande detector, six of which are clearly identifiable as candidate electron-neutrino events. The expectation would be for 1.5 such events in this data sample if neutrino oscillations do not take place. The observation implies the appearance of electron-neutrinos in the experiment, with a probability of 99.3%. At 90% confidence level (CL), the data are consistent with 0.03 < sin213 < 0.28.

MINOS far detector

The MINOS (Main Injector Neutrino Oscillation Search) in the US sends a muon-neutrino beam 735 km through the Earth from the Main Injector accelerator at Fermilab to a 5000-tonne detector in the Soudan Underground Laboratory in northern Minnesota. In the recently announced analysis, based on 8 × 1020 protons on target, the collaboration found a total of 62 electron neutrino-like events. Only 48 events would be expected if muon-neutrinos do not transform into electron neutrinos.

Compared with T2K, MINOS uses a different method and a different analysis technique to search for electron-neutrino appearance. The MINOS collaboration extracts 2sin2θ23sin213, and finds that it is less than 0.12 at 90% CL, with a best fit of 2sin2θ23sin213 = 0.04. This improves on results that the collaboration obtained with smaller data sets in 2009 and 2010. The latest results disfavour θ13 = 0 at 89% CL, with a range that is consistent with that measured by T2K.

More work and more data are needed to confirm both these measurements. The T2K experiment collected about 2% of the proposed number of events before the massive earthquake hit in March. Once J-PARC resumes producing muon-neutrinos, which is planned to happen by the end of 2011, the experiment will continue accumulating events. MINOS will continue to collect data until February 2012. In addition, three nuclear-reactor-based neutrino experiments, which use different techniques to measure sin213, are in the process of starting up.

ALICE goes in search of charmonium in the quark–gluon plasma

CCnew4_06_11

The ALICE collaboration has measured the nuclear modification (RAA) factor of J/Ψ mesons down to a transverse momentum (pT) equal to zero, in lead–lead (Pb–Pb) collisions at √sNN=2.76 TeV, delivered by the LHC in November 2010. The results, presented at the Quark Matter 2011 conference (Heavy ions in Annecy), hint at the recombination of charm and anticharm quarks in the quark–gluon plasma (QGP) formed in heavy-ion collisions at LHC energies.

The ALICE detector was conceived especially for measurements in heavy-ion collisions and is able to study QGP via comprehensive measurements of hadron abundances and correlations as well as of thermal photons. At LHC energies, new mechanisms of charmonium production in the QGP could occur. QCD calculations have predicted that a large number of charm quarks, around 50 c-c pairs, should be produced per central lead–lead collision at √sNN=2.76 TeV. These charm quarks would then coexist with the QGP during its dynamical evolution, like Brownian particles. A number of dynamical transport models predict that c and c quarks could then combine in later stages, leading to an enhancement of charmonium production in the most central Pb–Pb collisions.

ALICE detects charmonium down to pT=0 in two different rapidity domains: |y|<0.9 in the dielectron channel and 2.5<y<4 in the dimuon channel. The detection at low transverse momentum is crucial because the recombination of the charm and anticharm quarks is expected to be the main production mechanism for charmonium at low pT (pT<3 GeV/i>c). The different rapidity domains allow for the study of QGP with different charm densities.

In particular, ALICE has studied the nuclear modification factor, RAA, as a function of collision centrality for J/Ψ mesons. RAA is defined as the ratio of the yield measured in nucleus–nucleus (AA) collisions to that expected on the basis of the proton–proton yield scaled by the number of binary nucleon–nucleon collisions in the nucleus–nucleus reaction. The results from ALICE indicate that the J/Ψ RAA factor appears to show little dependence on centrality (see figure), a trend that is different from that observed at lower energies. The factor for central and mid-central collisions is larger at the LHC than was measured at lower centre-of-mass energy in gold–gold collisions in the PHENIX experiment at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider, Brookhaven. In complementary studies, the ATLAS and CMS collaborations at the LHC have measured a smaller J/ΨRAA factor at high pT (pT>6.5 GeV/c).

These observations contrast with expectations from the dissociation of charmonium through the mechanism of colour-screening in the QGP. They hint instead at the recombination of charm and anticharm quarks in the QGP as the main mechanism for J/Ψ production in central Pb–Pb collisions at LHC energies. ALICE’s analysis of J/Ψ production as a function of the pT and rapidity continues and should shed light on the topic soon.

ASACUSA measures antiproton mass with unprecedented accuracy

The Japanese-European ASACUSA experiment at CERN’s Antiproton Decelerator (AD) has reported a new measurement of the antiproton’s mass, accurate to about one part in a thousand million. This means that the measurement of the antiproton’s mass relative to the electron is now almost as accurate as that of the proton.

To make these measurements, the ASACUSA team first traps antiprotons inside antiprotonic helium, in which the negatively charged antiproton takes the place of an electron and occupies a Rydberg state, keeping it relatively far from the nucleus. The antiprotonic helium atoms thus live long enough to allow the frequencies of atomic transitions to be measured by laser spectroscopy. The frequencies depend on the ratio of the antiproton mass to the electron mass and ASACUSA has already used this technique to achieve record precision.

However, an important source of imprecision comes from Doppler broadening of the resonance observed when the laser is tuned to the transition frequency. The atoms move around, so that those moving towards and away from the laser beam experience slightly different frequencies. In the previous measurement in 2006, the ASACUSA team used just one laser beam, and the achievable accuracy was dominated by this effect. This time they have used two beams moving in opposite directions, with the result that the broadening for the two beams partly cancels out.

The resulting narrow spectral lines allowed the team to measure three transition frequencies with fractional precisions of 2.3–5 parts in 109. By comparing the results with three-body QED calculations, they find an antiproton-to-electron mass ratio of 1836.1526736(23), where the error (23) represents one standard deviation. This agrees with the proton-to-electron value, which is known to a similar precision.

COSY finds evidence for an exotic particle…

CCnew5_06_11

Experiments at the Jülich Cooler Synchrotron, COSY, have found evidence for a new complex state in the two-baryon system, with mass 2.37 GeV and width 70 MeV. The structure, containing six valence quarks, could constitute either an exotic compact particle or a hadronic molecule. The result could cast light on the long-standing question of whether there are eigenstates in the two-baryon system other than the deuteron ground-state. This has awaited an answer since Robert Jaffe first envisaged the possible existence of non-trivial six-quark configurations in QCD in 1977.

The new structure has been observed in high-precision measurements carried out by the WASA-at-COSY collaboration, using the Wide-Angle Shower Apparatus (WASA). The data exhibit a narrow isoscalar resonance-like structure in neutron–proton collisions for events where a deuteron is produced together with a pair of neutral pions. From the differential distributions, the spin-parity of the new system is deduced to be JP = 3+ and its main decay mode is via formation of a ΔΔ system below the nominal threshold of 2mΔ. The collaboration will further test the resonance hypothesis in elastic proton–neutron collisions with a polarized beam; the JP = 3+ partial waves should be dominated by the new structure, while its contribution to the elastic cross-section should be small.

CCnew6_06_11

The resonance structure also turns out to be intimately connected to the so-called ABC effect, in which the two pions produced in a nuclear fusion process are emitted preferentially in parallel. This 50-year-old puzzle, which is named after the initial letters of the surnames of its first observers A Abashian, N E Booth and K M Crowe, could now find its explanation in the way that such a resonance decays.

CDF discovers a heavy relative of the neutron

The CDF collaboration at Fermilab has announced the observation of the Ξ0b, the latest entry in the periodic table of baryons. Although Fermilab’s Tevatron is not a dedicated bottom-quark factory, the sophisticated particle detectors employed there and large integrated luminosity of proton–antiproton collisions delivered to the experiments have made it a haven for discovering and studying almost all of the known bottom baryons. Experiments there discovered the Σb baryons in 2006, observed the Ξb baryon in 2007 and found the Ωb in 2009. The lightest bottom baryon, the Λb, was discovered at CERN.

The complex decay pattern of the neutral Ξ0b has made the observation of this particle significantly more challenging than that of its charged sibling. Combing through an integrated luminosity of 4.2 fb–1 of proton–antiproton collisions produced at a centre-of-mass energy of 1.96 TeV, the CDF collaboration isolated 25 examples in which the particles emerging from a collision revealed the distinctive signature of the Ξ0b, through its decay to Ξ+cπ and the subsequent decay chain. The analysis established the discovery at a level of 6.8 σ and measured the mass of the Ξ0b as 5787.8 ± 5.0(stat) ± 1.3(syst) MeV/c2.

CDF also observed a similar number of events for the charged Ξb, in the decay Ξb → Ξ0cπ, never previously observed; this served as an independent cross-check of the analysis.

The LHC homes in on the Higgs

EPS-HEP 2011

In this issue, news from the LHC experiments focuses on a few highlights at the first big summer conference.

The outstanding performance of the LHC enabled the ATLAS and CMS collaborations to report remarkable progress in the hunt for the Higgs boson at EPS-HEP 2011. With an integrated luminosity of more than 1 fb–1 each – the original luminosity goal for all of 2011 – the experiments have been able to extend significantly the exclusion region for the Standard Model Higgs boson and to achieve impressive advances in extending sensitivity in other mass ranges.

In the Standard Model, the Higgs boson endows other particles and itself with mass. At the same time, the dominant decay mode of the Higgs depends on the value of its mass. Consequently, a comprehensive search for the Higgs must look in numerous decay modes.

At the conference, each collaboration reported results on several possible Higgs decay modes. These results were based on the full sample of data recorded by the end of June; the ability to search for so many decay modes so promptly reflected the efficiency of the experiments and the dedication of the collaborations. The most generally promising decay modes, such as H→γγ, H→W+W, and H→Z0Z0, were well covered by both experiments, while early results on H→τ+τ from CMS and on H→bb from ATLAS were also produced. In each experiment the results of these searches can be combined to optimize sensitivity across the range of possible Higgs boson masses.

The CMS and ATLAS Higgs limits presented at the conference are summarized by the solid curves in the two figures. These plots show the result of combining the limits from all of the analysed decay modes in each experiment in terms of the range of possible Standard Model Higgs mass that can be excluded with 95% confidence.

CCnew8_06_11

The two experiments presented similar exclusion ranges. They have now excluded mass ranges for the Higgs boson from 150 to 200 GeV and 300 to 450 GeV; they have also established expected limits within 50% of the Standard Model prediction for the region in between. Moreover, they are homing in on both the low mass region (around 115–150 GeV), which is preferred by electroweak measurements, and the high mass region above about 450 GeV. Throughout these regions, the experiments have already achieved sensitivities, reflected by the dashed curves, within a factor of 2–3 of the Standard Model cross-section.

While it is still early in the hunt for the Higgs, the ATLAS and CMS data also show some excesses that participants at the conference found tantalizing. For instance, both experiments currently see a small excess of candidate events at a mass of roughly 140 GeV. However, given the large range of masses and modes investigated by the two experiments and the as yet limited statistics, the limits observed do sometimes fluctuate from the limits that are expected. In addition, although the two detectors are independent, the results can be somewhat correlated because their background estimates make use of the same theoretical predictions.

Even as the LHC provides the experiments with more data, the painstaking process of combining the limits of the two experiments is currently underway. A combination with the experiments at Fermilab’s Tevatron, whose searches are particularly complementary in the low mass region, will also eventually be done.

Will the Higgs boson be discovered soon, or will the Standard Model Higgs boson be excluded as more data are accumulated? The answer at present is “watch this space”.

CMS and LHCb pull together in search for rare decay

EPS-HEP 2011

In this issue, news from the LHC experiments focuses on a few highlights at the first big summer conference.

The first major conference since the LHC started to deliver significant luminosities provided the opportunity for the experiments to begin to work together on certain results. CMS and LHCb joined forces in just this way in their search for the decay Bs→μ+μ. This rare decay mode is suppressed in the Standard Model, which predicts a branching ratio of (3.2 ± 0.2) × 10–9. It has recently gained much attention, with a preliminary measurement from the CDF experiment at Fermilab indicating a possible excess of events over the Standard Model expectation.

Now LHCb and CMS have combined their results based on 0.34 fb–1 and 1.14 fb–1 of proton–proton collisions, respectively, at a centre-of-mass energy of 7 TeV. The observed candidates in both experiments are consistent with the expectation from the sum of backgrounds and Standard Model signal. The combination results in an upper limit on the branching ratio for Bs→μ+μ of less than 1.1 × 10–8 at 95% confidence level (CL), which improves on the limits obtained by the separate experiments and represents the best existing limit on this decay. Enhancement of the branching ratio by more than 3.4 times the Standard Model prediction is excluded at 95% CL. However, there remains room for a contribution from new physics, so the experiments will press ahead with this search, as the data flood in from the LHC.

ATLAS takes a closer look at dibosons

CCnew10_06_11

EPS-HEP 2011

In this issue, news from the LHC experiments focuses on a few highlights at the first big summer conference.

A wealth of physics results from ATLAS emerged at EPS-HEP 2011, ranging from detailed measurements of strong and electroweak processes to a spectrum of searches for new physical processes using the full 2011 dataset collected up until the end of June, and comprising up to 1.2 fb–1 of analysed data. As with the Higgs searches, constraints on other new processes now probe mass ranges that have substantially increased with respect to 2010 data alone, but no evidence has yet appeared for physics beyond the Standard Model. Several measurements also benefited by including the 2011 data, such as measurements of the cross-section for the production of pairs of top quarks with a precision of 8%, and a more than 7σ observation of electroweak production of single top quarks.

The collected integrated luminosity has now brought processes involving the dibosons WW, WZ and ZZ under the microscope at ATLAS. Diboson production at the LHC is of great interest because it tests the fundamental gauge structure of the Standard Model. The production of the pairs involves boson self-couplings that are precisely predicted by the Standard Model, so any deviation from the expected values would be an indication of new physics.

Of the three dibosons, the production of ZZ pairs is particularly rare. The Z bosons were observed in ATLAS via their decays to electrons or muons, giving a very clean signature of four isolated leptons with high transverse momentum. Electrons were identified from a cluster in the fine-granularity ATLAS electromagnetic calorimeter, muons from a track in the muon spectrometer, in each case matched to a track measured in the high-precision inner detector. In events with four leptons, pairs of oppositely charged electrons or muons were combined to form Z candidates.

The figure shows a plot of the mass of one electron or muon pair against the mass of the second pair. The ZZ signal is clearly seen as a cluster of events around the Z boson mass, 91 GeV, for both pairs. ATLAS thus sees 12 events that are consistent with ZZ production, with an expected background of 0.3 events, and measures a cross-section of 8.4+2.7–2.4 pb compared with the Standard Model prediction of 6.5 pb.

ATLAS has also measured cross-sections for WW and WZ production, again using leptonic final states. All values are in agreement with Standard Model expectations, and the WZ and ZZ measurements have been used to constrain gauge boson self-couplings. These constraints are comparable with, and in some cases tighter than, those from measurements at the Large Electron–Positron collider at CERN and at Fermilab’s Tevatron.

CMS in search of new physics

EPS-HEP 2011

In this issue, news from the LHC experiments focuses on a few highlights at the first big summer conference.

CCnew11_06_11

The CMS collaboration contributed more than 30 new or updated physics analyses at EPS-HEP 2011. The most eagerly awaited results probably concerned searches for the Higgs boson as well as for new physics beyond the Standard Model. A highly anticipated search is the one for supersymmetry (SUSY), and the corresponding search for the production of new heavy supersymmetry particles. If SUSY exists in nature at the tera-electron-volt scale, it could solve many of the outstanding issues in particle physics, such as the gauge hierarchy problem. It could also deliver a natural candidate particle to explain the high density of dark matter in the universe.

The CMS collaboration released several new analyses at EPS-HEP 2011 on the search for SUSY, based on the full data sample of about 1 fb–1 at 7 TeV in the centre-of-mass, collected by the end of June 2011 and analysed in time for the conference. These analyses search for a variety of characteristic event final-state topologies: e.g. events with a large missing transverse momentum plus either only jets, or leptons and jets. Techniques already used to analyse the 2010 data sample, based on 30 times less data, were further refined and used with the 2011 data.

The results are remarkable, testing regions in the parameter space of SUSY theory where the squarks and gluinos (the supersymmetric partners of quarks and gluons) can be as heavy as 1 TeV. Unfortunately there is no sign so far of the production of SUSY particles. With these latest results, CMS has substantially reduced the phase space where SUSY can hide, particularly in the so-called constrained models such as the Constrained Minimal Supersymmetric extension of the Standard Model (CMSSM). Figure 1 illustrates the impressive reach of the CMS analyses with respect to other experiments in the plane of the universal scalar and gaugino masses at the GUT scale (m0 and m1/2, respectively) of the CMSSM.

CCnew12_06_11

The collaboration has also released its first paper based on the 2011 dataset of 1 fb–1, namely on the search for very high mass resonances in events that have at least two jets with a large transverse momentum in the final state. Jets are observed in the detectors as sprays of particles ejected from the interaction point in a given direction – that is, the direction of the original parton produced in the hard scattering of the collision, or in the decay of a heavy new particle. Examples of possible heavy new particles that can be studied in such di-jet invariant mass analyses are new gauge bosons, graviton resonances, string resonances, and more exotic objects that couple via the strong force, such as axigluons or colour octet states. Each one of these particles is predicted in one or more models for new physics beyond the Standard Model.

CMS has now examined the di-jet mass for mass values up to 4 TeV. No significant sign of di-jet resonances has been found and, as figure 2 shows, various other new particles have now been excluded in the range of 1–4 TeV, depending on the model and particle species.

The search for SUSY and other new physics signatures at the LHC is in a very early stage – an important increase in luminosity is expected before the end of 2012. These first data are beginning to disfavour the simplest and more constrained models, but the range of possibilities that need to be explored further is vast. As David Gross said in the concluding remarks at the conference: “Nobody promised it would be easy.”

bright-rec iop pub iop-science physcis connect